Stereogum's TOP 25 ALBUMS OF 2012 So Far

The year isn’t half over yet. We know that. But since everyone starts unveiling their year-end lists in November, we figured we wouldn’t be too far out of pocket if we unveiled our favorites of the 2012 calendar year the week before Memorial Day.

Our favorite album of the year (so far) is the one on which a talented young band teamed up with a production hero of the ’90s and immersed themselves in the decade’s hard, chunky, scraping, anthemic rock music. There’s no drift at all in Cloud Nothings’ Attack On Memory — just forward drive, rendered with style and conviction. That same Clinton-era ferocity is on display in a bunch of the other albums that appear on this list. Japandroids, Screaming Females both ran with it, and so, in their own ways, did Torche and Ceremony. Other albums don’t necessarily draw on that decade’s style, but they do sprint into chaotic combat in refreshingly concrete ways: El-P, Sleigh Bells, Killer Mike, Death Grips.

But it doesn’t make too much sense to impose a narrative on this list. There’s plenty of druggy float in the albums from Beach House and Future and the Chromatics, and plenty of glamorous sheen in the records from Chairlift and Rick Ross and Kindness. The albums that appear on our list don’t really share too much in common, except this: They’re all deeply personal, idiosyncratic visions. That, and we like all of them. Check out our list below.

STEREOGUM’S TOP 25 ALBUMS OF 2012 SO FAR

Heems - Nehru Jackets25 HeemsNehru Jackets (Greedhead)

Ceremony - Zoo24 CeremonyZoo (Matador)

Willis Earl Beal - Acousmatic Sorcery23 Willis Earl BealAcousmatic Sorcery (Hot Charity/XL)

Grimes - Visions22 GrimesVisions (4AD/Arbutus)

Kindness - World You Need A Change Of Mind21 KindnessWorld You Need A Change Of Mind (Polydor/Female Energy)

Spiritualized - Sweet Heart Sweet Light20 SpiritualizedSweet Heart Sweet Light (Fat Possum)

Chromatics - Kill For Love19 ChromaticsKill For Love (Italians Do It Better)

Death Grips - The Money Store18 Death GripsThe Money Store (Epic)

Frankie Rose - Interstellar17 Frankie RoseInterstellar (Slumberland)

Tanlines - Mixed Emotions16 TanlinesMixed Emotions (True Panther)

Torche - Harmonicraft 15 TorcheHarmonicraft (Volcom)

Lotus Plaza - Spooky Action At A Distance14 Lotus PlazaSpooky Action At A Distance (Kranky)

Julia Holter - Ekstasis13 Julia HolterEkstasis (Rvng Intl.)

Action Bronson And Party Supplies - Blue Chips12 Action Bronson & Party SuppliesBlue Chips (self-released)

Killer Mike - R.A.P. Music11 Killer MikeR.A.P. Music (Williams Street)

Future - Pluto10 FuturePluto (Epic/A1/Free Bandz)

Sleigh Bells - Reign Of Terror09 Sleigh BellsReign Of Terror (Mom + Pop)

Rick Ross - Rich Forever08 Rick RossRich Forever (Maybach Music)

Screaming Females - Ugly07 Screaming FemalesUgly (Don Giovanni)

El-P - Cancer For Cure06 El-PCancer For Cure (Fat Possum)

Beach House - Bloom05 Beach HouseBloom (Sub Pop)

Japandroids - Celebration Rock04 JapandroidsCelebration Rock (Polyvinyl)

Chairlift - Something03 ChairliftSomething (Columbia)

The Walkmen - Heaven02 The WalkmenHeaven (Fat Possum)

Cloud Nothings - Attack On Memory01 Cloud NothingsAttack On Memory (Carpark)

//

Here’s that list in a more scannable format:

25 HeemsNehru Jackets
24 CeremonyZoo
23 Willis Earl BealAcousmatic Sorcery
22 GrimesVisions
21 KindnessWorld You Need A Change Of Mind
20 SpiritualizedSweet Heart Sweet Light
19 ChromaticsKill For Love
18 Death GripsThe Money Store
17 Frankie RoseInterstellar
16 TanlinesMixed Emotions
15 TorcheHarmonicraft
14 Lotus PlazaSpooky Action At A Distance
13 Julia HolterEkstasis
12 Action Bronson & Party SuppliesBlue Chips
11 Killer MikeR.A.P. Music
10 FuturePluto
09 Sleigh BellsReign Of Terror
08 Rick RossRich Forever
07 Screaming FemalesUgly
06 El-PCancer For Cure
05 Beach HouseBloom
04 JapandroidsCelebration Rock
03 ChairliftSomething
02 The WalkmenHeaven
01 Cloud NothingsAttack On Memory

//

As always, coming up with the master countdown meant leaving out some personal favorites of our four staff members. Here are those…

HONORABLE MENTIONS
SCOTT
01 Sun Kil MoonAmong The Leaves
02 Wymond MilesUnder The Pale Moon
03 Field MusicPlumb
04 Moonface With SinaiBravery
05 Sharon Van EttenTramp

AMRIT
01 Mount EerieClear Moon
02 Vijay IyerAccelerando
03 PO PODope Boy Magick
04 John TalabotƒIN
05 The MenOpen Your Heart

TOM
01 Jack WhiteBlunderbuss
02 Schoolboy QHabits & Consequences
03 TragedyDarker Days Ahead
04 Killa Kyleon & MouseWelcome To The Fish Fry
05 Split CraniumSplit Cranium

CORBAN
01 Lil BGod’s Father
02 THEESatisfactionawE naturalE
03 Chief KeefBack From The Dead
04 Best CoastThe Only Place
05 Rye RyeGo! Pop! Bang!

//

That’s a solid chunk of the year’s most notable releases to date, though obviously not all of them. Feel free to nominate those that we missed.

Comments (328)
  1. That moment when you start to reconsider when you say Pitchfork doesn’t have criteria…

  2. First Aid Kit’s album The Lion’s Roar is still my number one so far.

  3. No love for Polica?

  4. i mean, it’s not technically out for 5 more days, but since it’s already streaming on NPR, and it’s also an incredibly piece of work: What We Saw from the Cheap Seats by Regina Spektor!

  5. Easily my top thus far…

    Zeus- Busting Visions
    Plants and Animals – The End of That
    Yukon Blonde – Tiger Talk

  6. grimes and death grips should def be up there- i don’t agree with a 20 slot for either of those- just sayin’ those albums are killer.

  7. I think the Magnetic Fields record got an undeservedly bad rap. I know it’s not on the same level as Merritt’s best work, but that’s only in terms of emotional effect. It’s easy to hear how he can probably write these songs in his sleep, and people tend to forget that that in itself is commendable. Every song on that album is catchy and memorable, just lacking the depth that we’d want from Merritt.

    Oh, and it’s insane that no one on staff thought to mention Burial, Perfume Genius, Here We Go Magic, Royal Headache, or Lower Dens. The Shins’ album also has a lot of staying power for me, and I was in no way prepared to enjoy that one.

  8. Thank God school ends this week for me. I’ve missed not being able to be up to speed with the year’s music. Have yet to check several of these out.

  9. I’m still listening to Suckers – Candy Salad. Where’s the love?

  10. Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see

  11. Not a bad round-up at all. I have to say for myself that (of the ones I’ve heard, obviously) 2012 has had a nearly endless supply of records I like and yet very few that I’m convinced I’ll come back to once the year’s out. Beach House, Chromatics, Chairlift, and Grimes are the exceptions. I am looking forward to Walkmen and Japandroids but based on the early singles I’m not expecting to be floored by either one.

  12. I agree this year is underwhelming so far. However, 2010 was my favorite recent year, and most of the bands responsible for a lot of that year’s best music are coming around the cycle for new releases later this year, so I’m holding my breath for 2012.

    Also, Bloom should be higher. Like, number two.

  13. JAPANDROIDS >>>>>>>>> CHAIRLIFT

  14. Wow, only record on this list I’ve hear in full is the Beach House album, and I’ve just tried listening to the number 1 on this list and found it to be not to my taste at all.

    I must be lame huh?

  15. Alabama Shakes put out an absolutely amazing record! And they had so much buzz going too, I can’t believe there is no mention of them!

    Has anyone said anything about Foxy Shazam yet? That band is unbelievable and they never get any recognition from blogs like this. . .

    • I think you’re right. I’ve never been a huge Foxy Shazam fan, but The Church of Rock n Rool is filled with some really catchy glam rock. They’re one of those bands that’s really popular but doesn’t get love from any of my fav sites, like Cage the Elephant or Portugal the Man.

  16. Djanga Django
    Dr. John
    Allo Darlin’
    Andrew Bird
    Anaïs Mitchell
    Jack White

    …All deserving of top 25, in my opinion. And Burial’s Kindred EP deserves mention for being better than at least 85% of the rest of these albums.

  17. Wow, no Dr Dog- Be The Void, def one of the best bands out there today! Lower Dens- Nootropics should be on there too

  18. Wondering how Dry the River “Shallow Bed” slipped through the cracks on this one.

  19. Is this a hip hop site???? fuckin’ hell! you are boring anyway… enough already!!!

  20. Anyone else fall more in love with Of Montreal this year than ever before?

  21. What about Galaxy Garden by Lone? I listen to that and Sorrow and Extinction more often than anything else

  22. I don’t understand why Action Bronson’s boring ass substitute for a ghostface release is 12. Schoolboy Q should definitely be up there, and I would even put Ab-soul over Bronson.

  23. Death Grips and Japandroids need to switch positions. Wasn’t too keen on the recording aesthetics of Celebration Rock.

  24. Always fun putting things in order:

    Father John Misty – Fear Fun
    Damien Jurado – Maraqopa
    Spiritualized – Sweet Heart Sweet Light
    The Flaming Lips – The Flaming Lips and Heady Fwends
    Jack White – Blunderbuss
    Beach House – Bloom
    Chromatics – Kill for Love
    Django Django – Django Django
    John Talabot – ƒIN
    Dr. John – Locked Down
    Lambchop – Mr. M
    Andrew Bird – Break It Yourself
    M. Ward – A Wasteland Companion
    The 2 Bears – Be Strong
    VCMG – Ssss
    Simian Mobile Disco – Unpatterns
    Caetano Veloso and David Byrne – Live at Carnegie Hall
    Tindersticks – The Something Rain
    Brendan Benson – What Kind of World
    Miike Snow – Happy to You
    The Dandy Warhols – This Machine
    The Magnetic Fields – Love at the Bottom of the Sea
    Delta Spirit – Delta Spirit
    fun. – Some Nights
    Lana Del Rey – Born to Die

  25. My favorite so far is An Awesome Wave by alt-J Have a listen here: http://soundcloud.com/alt-j/sets/an-awesome-wave/

  26. I think john talobt must be in the top 10 list. it`s very chill sound. and where is perfume genius?? put your back n 2 it is his best album ever. But gum`s choice is good, i agree the cloud nothings, walkmen are best album on their career

  27. Zero Garage Rock records :-\

  28. Big fan of most of these albums… but am I the only one listening to Sebastien Tellier’s new album “My God is Blue”? Top 5 material for sure…

  29. It’s all about Sara Bareilles’ new EP “Once Upon Another Time”! loving the song STAY. http://www.sarabmusic.com

  30. Lotus Plaza should be #1. Some seriously well-written pop songs.

  31. Am I the only one who thinks that Cloud Nothings are way over rated?

  32. Bloom is definitely my number one!

  33. People still listen to hip hop?

  34. I really liked Trust – TRST and Santigold’s albums

  35. Killer Mike should be way higher. Way better than the Rick Ross mixtape.

  36. OH, and by the way

    Father John Misty – Fear Fun
    Damien Jurado – Maraqopa !!!!!!
    Dr. John – Locked Down.

  37. What about Jr Dave Mathews wannabe with the kidney stone sympathy votes on american idol?! COME ON NOWWW, that kids an open-mic semi-GENIUS!

  38. No list is complete without Joseph Arthur’s “Redemption City” double disc. It’s genius. http://www.josepharthur.com/2012/?page_id=400

  39. A Place To Bury Strangers- Onwards To The Wall
    Broken Water- Tempest
    Every time I Die- Ex Lives
    Silversun Pickups- Neck Of The Woods

  40. A Place To Bury Strangers- Onwards To The Wall
    Broken Water- Tempest
    Every time I Die- Ex Lives
    Silversun Pickups- Neck Of The Woods

  41. John Frusciante will be releasing an EP and an LP this year which will mostly likely be brilliant and go unnoticed by the majority of these sorts of indie music sites.

  42. Bear in Heaven, Here We Go Magic.

  43. No @Among_Wolves “This Is A Wave Goodbye”? This list is completely null and void. The best band out of Baltimore are these gents, not Best Coast.

  44. If only you’d waited a week you could have added Alt-J to this list.

  45. Kill for love should def be top 5.
    Also include….
    Earth – angels of darkness, demons of light 2
    Andrew Bird – break it yourself

  46. How in the world did Of Monsters and Men’s “My Head Is An Animal” not make this list? It’s certainly one of the best albums out right now.

  47. Well….I guess isn’t going to get any attention at this point. But I wanna put in my cents:

    15) Bear in Heaven: “I Love You, It’s Cool”
    14) Pseudo Kids: “Stay Calm” EP
    13) Spiritualized: “Sweet Heart Sweet Light”
    12) Earth: “Angels of Darkness, Demons of Light II”
    11) Schoolboy Q: “Habits & Contradictions”
    10) Frankie Rose: “Interstellar”
    9) Lotus Plaza: “Spooky Action at a Distance”
    8) Loma Prieta: “IV”
    7) Andrew Bird: “Break It Yourself”
    6) Burial: “Kindred” EP
    5) Conan: “Monnos”
    4) Beach House: “Bloom”
    3) Drudkh “Eternal Turn of the Wheel”
    2) John Talabot: “fin”
    1) Cloud Nothings: “Attack on Memory”

  48. I thought I’d have some measure of complaint, but I honestly agree. Attack on Nothing really is the best album of the year so far. And I’m a HUGE Beach House fan.

    The year started out a little slow for me, but so many good albums came out in May.

  49. The lack of Perfume Genius is disappointing… my top album of the year so far

  50. dEUS: Following Sea is missing.

  51. +1 Grimes, Cloud Nothings and Japandroids

    Maybe King Tuff now too?

  52. Alt-J’s An Awesome Wave really is awesome. Prepare for this tidal wave that started in the UK to arrive on US shores soon! Listen on soundcloud for now. http://soundcloud.com/alt-j/sets/an-awesome-wave/

  53. I can’t believe people are still falling for Sleigh Bells as anything other than people who use a ton of compression in the studio and then can’t come close to reproducing the sound correctly live. The only reason anyone even heard them is that they sampled “Can you get to that?” so seamlessly that people thought it was their own guitar part…

  54. alt-j and DIIV’s releases are killer. Also, that new album by The Antlers is shaping up to be really awesome considering the two tracks already released.

  55. In the Belly of the Brazen Bull.

  56. I’m sorry, but y’all forgot about Metric….

    Metric’s Synthetica is a brilliant light in an otherwise dark, uninspiring sea of BORING.

    Y’all just don’t get it.

  57. Burial-Kindred
    Liars-WIXIW
    Port St. Willow-Holiday

  58. Well well. No signs of “Sweet Sour” from “Band of Skulls”, which is absolutely breath taking nor Django Django and its ambitious first album.

    Must have missed something or what ?

    ;)

  59. I like my list a lot…some of these were left out on yours: http://audiofuzz.tumblr.com/post/26846881946/top-albums-of-2012-so-far

  60. Much as I love the Walkmen, Heaven isn’t really worth writing home about. A friend of mine compared it to the Stereophonics. Nuff said!

  61. TRUST – TRST (2012)

    synthpop community choice

  62. I always check these lists to see if I have missed out on any records, but it seems like you are the one who have overlooked some.

    Simian Ghost – Youth
    Kishi Bashi – 151a
    Silver Firs – Silver Firs
    Wowser Bowser – Wowser Bowser
    Damien Jurado – Maraqopa
    AU – Both Lights
    Highasakite – All thats floats will rain
    Oscar and the wolf – Summer skin
    A Classic Education – Call it blazing

  63. The Mars Volta!?

  64. Billy Woods – History Will Absolve Me

  65. Now that Gossamer is out it definitely need to be thrown into the mix..I’ve really enjoyed seeing a darker side of Passion Pit. Here’s a link to one of their new vids: http://pitchfork.com/news/47291-video-passion-pit-constant-conversations/

  66. Now that Gossamer is out it definitely needs to be thrown into the mix..I’ve really enjoyed seeing a darker side of Passion Pit. Here’s a link to one of their new vids: http://pitchfork.com/news/47291-video-passion-pit-constant-conversations/

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.

%s1 / %s2