Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

Scott Lapatine | September 21, 2012 - 5:35 pm

This week in Stereogum … we chatted with Aimee Mann, Bat For Lashes, Ben Gibbard, Matt & Kim, and Billy Corgan. We ranked the Top 10 Indie Rock Docs, Pixies’ 10 Best Songs, and the Replacements’ discography. Fiona got arrested, AnCo kicked off their tour, and Grizzly Bear released the Album Of The Week (Month? (Year?)). Let’s see what you had to say about all this, and who said it best and worst!

THIS WEEK’S 10 HIGHEST RATED COMMENTS

#10

Clay Graham | Sep 20th Score:22

I didn’t read any of the article and now I’m commenting on it.

Posted in: Billy Corgan On The State Of The Alternative Community
#8 Tommy | Sep 14th Score:25

I fucked up big time.

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments
#7 haiimalex | Sep 20th Score:26

“I know what you’re thinking: a seemingly throwaway track like ‘Tame’ has no business at the top of this list.”
pretty much yah

Posted in: Pixies’ 10 Best Songs
#6 woozefa | Sep 20th Score:29

not til you learn the actual name of the song.

Posted in: Pixies’ 10 Best Songs
#5 plb102 | Sep 20th Score:32

seriously? I bet she’d shank the fuck out of someone if she had to.

Posted in: Fiona Apple Arrested For Drug Possession
#4 Corban Goble | Sep 14th Score:33

In closing, Swerve.

Posted in: Premature Evaluation: Kanye West Presents G.O.O.D. Music Cruel Summer
#3 godsdog | Sep 14th Score:34

I’m not particularly witty or incisive – BUT I do love to see my name at the top of lists.

SO – I’m asking professional-ish Stereogummers to upvote all my comments.

In return you will receive my gratitude for 1 week – or if you live locally; meth and blow jobs

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments
#2 thomasbrownester | Sep 20th Score:40

Hey?

Posted in: Pixies’ 10 Best Songs
#1 Dr. Feelgood | Sep 20th Score:63

What she needs is a good defense. Probably feeling like a criminal right now.

Posted in: Fiona Apple Arrested For Drug Possession

THIS WEEK’S 5 LOWEST RATED COMMENTS

#5

Rob Casper | Sep 20th Score:-9

hey i wonder why this $ite often exclude$ obviou$ choice$ when picking the$e list$

Posted in: Pixies’ 10 Best Songs
#4 mrsimple0 | Sep 18th Score:-9

I resent that these bands are considered “indie”. It’s lazy journalism at best, and at worst it’s co-opting several generations of music into one for the sake of an article. Second… ‘best of’ lists are stupid.

Posted in: The 10 Best Indie Rock Documentaries
#3 ironic mustache | Sep 14th Score:-15

Another slow day in music news, another “Worst to Best” list. Does anyone really need to see these albums ranked like this? Who cares? Stereogum is getting awfully close to pitchforkland these days.

Posted in: Pavement Albums From Worst To Best
#2 elitist | Sep 17th Score:-16

Steve Albini is an untalented douchebag, who should really shut the F up because his opinion does not matter, to anyone. And why does he even care about what she does. Shut up dude, you are nobody

Posted in: Amanda Palmer: Albini Is A Grumpy Fuck / Albini: She’s Gross
#1 rubberjohnny0829 | Sep 20th Score:-25

i don’t know which picture she looks worse in. lay off the heroin, slut.

Posted in: Fiona Apple Arrested For Drug Possession

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR’S CHOICE (SCOTT)

Mephisto Pheles | Sep 20th Score:15

Thank you T. Cole Rachel for such an outstanding interview, it’s the second one I read from you in a couple of days (Aimee Mann was the first). And thanks to Billy Corgan too of course, for being who he is.

Posted in: Billy Corgan On The State Of The Alternative Community

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR’S CHOICE (AMRIT)

Kelly Conaboy | Sep 18th Score:1

I WILL WATCH IT TOO!

Posted in: Watch The Penn Badgley-As-Jeff Buckley Movie Trailer
36