Michael Cera, Tim & Eric, Reggie Watts, and Sarah Silverman are the creators of the YouTube channel JASH, and they frequently bring in other comedians to collaborate with them. Today found Michael Cera, Jenny Slate, Luc Laurent, and Islands man (and Cera bandmate) Nick Thorburn posing as a fake garage band by the name of Molly & The Daves playing a tribute to Meredith Brooks’ “Bitch.” It’s beautifully awkward and uncomfortable — even down to the in-character written messages during the credits. Someone needs to start a petition to get an entire Molly & The Daves album made. Watch below.

“Bitch” by Meredith Brooks was originally released on April 1st, 1997.