5Best11

This week, 2014 kicked into top gear, musically speaking, leaving us with way more than five great songs competing for space in our list of the week’s best. We had to leave out truly excellent cuts from Protomartyr, Woods Of Desolation, and Primitive Parts, as well as long-awaited new tracks from longtime favorites like Jenny Lewis and Liars. You could probably make a case for that list comprising an alternate and almost equally impressive 5 Best. Almost — but not quite. So what did make it? This:

5. Chlöe Howl – “This Song’s Not About You” (Demo)

We’d heard a few promising tracks from Chlöe Howl at this point, but wow, this is next level. Starting with its pounding intro, “This Song’s Not About You” charges through its choruses, verses, and many, many hooks with a growing confidence. Howl only builds momentum as the song progress, all the better for a song about leaving a bad relationship. Considering this is only a demo, it doesn’t look like she’ll be slowing down anytime soon. –Miles

4. Tree – “Probably Nu It”

We’ve written several times over that young Chicago rap circa 2014 can’t be so easily polarized into the chilling lunkheaded drill music of Chief Keef and Fredo Santana vs. the brainy, sensitive expressionism of Chance The Rapper and Vic Mensa. Tree might be our surest living proof of that thesis. There is no easy label for “Probably Nu It,” a song that manages to bang even as it creeps on the low. Even Tree’s own clever “soul-trap” designation doesn’t cut it for a song so understated, albeit one that does sketch lines between Gucci Mane and bare-bones blues. This music is not quite revolutionary, but it’s strikingly individual all the same. –Chris

3. Real Estate – “Talking Backwards”

I’ve written at length about bands that thrive by simply doing what they do, bands that are actually better off not evolving, bands that respond to the objection “It all sounds the same!” with a hearty “So what?” Whether you put up with such lack of progression is almost entirely dependent on whether you enjoyed the starting point. So people who don’t really care for Real Estate can scroll down, and those of us who can’t get enough can glory in the glow of what promises to be another splendid LP. “Talking Backwards” is as simple, straightforward, and lightweight as Real Estate songs always are. Built from a basic chord progression, it drifts forward casually, overlaid with gentle jangle and sighing swoons. Real Estate’s signature sound has come into crisper focus since the band’s early years, but even in hi-fi they still sound like a dream. –Chris

2. Sun Kil Moon – “Ben’s My Friend”

On his staggering new album Benji, Sun Kil Moon’s Mark Kozelek deals with the weightiest possible themes: Death, impending death, the certainty of death, virginity-loss memories, bad knees. But Kozelek doesn’t work in big gestures, and so those ideas come out in sideways, offhand ways, through his casual and conversational lyricism. Case in point: Album closer “Ben’s My Friend,” mostly structured as a story about our middle-aged narrator going to see the Postal Service live, remembering when his friend Ben Gibbard was nowhere near as famous as he was, feeling too old and uncool and out-of-place to even be there. Kozelek’s lyrics and delivery tell us that it’s no big deal, but those of us who have experienced something similar know that it is a big deal — it’s absolutely a big deal — to realize that you’re, in some ways, obsolete. But the jazzy, expansive splay of the music is something else, too — a prettier, more evocative piece of sound than anything Kozelek’s friend Ben has managed in years. –Tom

1. Childbirth – “I Only Fucked You As A Joke”

One one level, it’s top-shelf alt-rock novelty: Two minutes of choppy and minimal guitar and quotable lyrical sneer, a Tumblr-era “Valley Girl” or “Detachable Penis.” But if you let the song linger, it becomes something else: cold, hard, brutal realness. This is pick-up culture blues — one of the meanest things one person can say to another person rendered as giddy garage-punk, like practically every song Bratmobile ever recorded. One line here — “Ooh baby, I can’t make good decisions everyday” — takes every moonily passive-aggressive Drake line ever, balls it up, and throws it in the garbage. (Bonus: Everything on Childbirth’s streaming-on-Bandcamp album It’s A Girl! is nearly this much fun, even if it doesn’t cut as deep.) –Tom

Comments (17)
  1. Aw…was kind of hoping that Adult Jazz track would sneak in somewhere. Also, that Sun Kil Moon track is stellar.

  2. Absolutely LOVE that Childbirth track! I downloaded the whole It’s A Girl! album through bandcamp after you guys posted about it earlier in the week, worth every penny.

  3. Love the Sun Kil Moon track. Not 100% sure they all count as tracks from this week, but my other favorites I discovered this week were James Vincent McMorrow “Red Dust”, Real Estate “Talking Backwards”, Son Lux “Lost it to Trying”, East India Youth “Dripping Down”, and Eternal Summers “Gouge”.

  4. The Childbirth song kind of reminds me of Pissed Jeans. Funny but serious. Speaking of Pissed Jeans, how that album didn’t make Stereogum’s top 50 is beyond comprehension.

  5. The Real Estate song was much better than that Childbirth crap. Give me a break.

    • “BUT IT’S EDGY BECAUSE IT’S FEMINIST WHICH MEANS IT MUST BE GOOD!!!” – Popular music sites

      • Or it’s just a fun, catchy bit of bratty pop-punk? I don’t even think a woman making fun of a man (also, the gender of the target of ridicule is never specified, I’m just assuming it’s a man) automatically qualifies something as “feminist”.

        • Well she does sing “I hope I’m not pregnant,” implying the subject is a man, but I don’t think any of us here voted for that song because it’s a feminist statement (though I can only speak for myself in that regard); it’s just a really great song. FWIW I actually don’t think it IS a feminist statement, or any kind of statement. It’s just a miniaturist short story with a great vocal and melody set to an elemental punk track. I love the Real Estate song too, though.The top three probably could have appeared in any order and I would have been fine with it.

        • Pitchfork’s review dropped the “f” bomb in their review (” If you happen to have an ex who likes to talk about how feminists don’t have senses of humor, this would be a funny song to email them…”), which is why I now have that definition of Childbirth burned into my skull. Kip Berman of the Pains of Being Pure at Heart made an interesting comment about feminism a few months back (I know, I know — “mansplaining” y’all!) which I think would fit this scenario in that while the movement is important, making a genre out of it undermines its intentions. I didn’t read Stereogum’s write-up of the song, so I cannot chide them, but I felt Pitchfork’s assessment was basically telling me that there’s a new feminist gimmick punk joke band out and this is their funniest song.

          • It always comes back to the P word doesn’t it?

          • Yep, they rule this game pretty much. My favorite criticism this week came from Brandon Soderberg at SPIN, a former P4k writer himself who said in a series of tweets:

            “P4K scooping up premieres for their Advance thing and then tanking those obscure records with middling reviews is perverse

            That p4k is now come-lately to a lot of stuff, scoops up the premiere of stuff they’re late to and then dismisses the record is strange.

            that’s the most toxic element of Pitchfork, the weird desire to own artists and knock down the ones they didn’t get to first or can’t own.”

            Our job as readers and listeners is to watch dog what these sites are doing and calling them out on their shit. Comment sections are a good place for that.

  6. Really been loving the new Death Vessel stuff, surprised Mercury Dime didn’t make this week’s list.

  7. I thought for sure Perfect Pussy’s “Driver” would make this list. I wasn’t the only one in thinking it was amazing, was I?

    • Oh man, what a slight now that you mention it! By the way, David, I never knew you posted here! Now we can talk without clogging up tweet feeds!

  8. I’ve been listening to the new Liars track non-stop, and was very surprised not to see it here. WHY DOES MY FAVOURITE SONG NEVER MAKE THE LIST!

    Sorry, Gummers — I had to get that out of my system.

    Carry on.

  9. What about something that Fiona Apple is cookin up?

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.

%s1 / %s2