Cults have played their share of late-night shows since we met them, but for reasons I can’t quite figure out, they seem more like a Letterman band than a Fallon or Leno one. And last night, they brought their smooth festival-pop to the Late Show, playing “Keep Your Head Up,” a track from their sophomore album Static, and earning a “nice goin'” from Dave. Watch the performance below.

Static is out now on Columbia.