A.V. Club’s Undercover series just wrapped up recently with a Gwar cover courtesy of Iron & Wine, but it’s back for the holidays with four new holiday covers. This week’s is courtesy of the Hold Steady’s Craig Finn and singer-songwriter Esmé Patterson, who take on Low’s 1999 original “Just Like Christmas” from their holiday-themed EP. Finn says it’s his favorite Christmas song! Watch below.

Here’s the original: