Shut Up, Dude 2/3/12

This week our old friends Jack White and M.I.A. returned, and despite unseasonably pleasant weather (at least in NYC) you stuck around your laptops to welcome them with accolades and constructive criticism. We appreciate it! We also appreciate your in-jokes! Let’s take a look at the week’s highest and lowest rated comments and see who we appreciated most!

THIS WEEK’S 10 HIGHEST RATED COMMENTS

#10  godsdog | Jan 30th Score:14

Decaff is brewing at my house.

Posted in: James Murphy Coffee Coming Soon?
#9 

Michael Robenalt | Jan 30th Score:14

Hmmm…..Eleanor Fried burger

Posted in: Eleanor Friedberger – “Heaven” Video
#8  djfreshie | Jan 28th Score:15

The Rubberjohnny “Boiling Point” award

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments
#7 

Trevor Morrison | Jan 27th Score:17

I mean, after reading the worst comments of the week this is the only think of:

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments
#6  dj possum waffles freshie | Feb 2nd Score:18

Why do I have to keep fixing these things for you?

Posted in: Stereogum Buzz Chart: Week Of 1/29/12
#5  donnytilla | Jan 31st Score:18

SHABAZZ PALACES WAS GREAT UP UNTIL, OH SHIT THAT’S RIGHT THEY ARE THE SHABAZZALACES OF ALLLLLLLL TIME!!!!

SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) poopSHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;) SHABAZZ ;)

Posted in: Jack White – “Love Interruption”
#4  theupswing | Jan 30th Score:22

New York, I Love You, But You’re Bringing Me Grounds?

Posted in: James Murphy Coffee Coming Soon?
#3  plb102 | Jan 30th Score:22

Finally, a divisive female musician for us to discuss!

Posted in: M.I.A. – “Bad Girls”
#2 

Kyle Culbert | Jan 30th Score:23

what a rebel.

Posted in: Jack White – “Love Interruption”
#1 

Ryan Little | Jan 30th Score:27

Is LCD Groundsystem too obvious?

Posted in: James Murphy Coffee Coming Soon?

THIS WEEK’S 5 LOWEST RATED COMMENTS

#5 

Panagiotis Vouyoukliotis | Jan 30th Score:-9

MIA y u no make good music no more!!!

Posted in: M.I.A. – “Bad Girls”
#4  rubberjohnny0829 | Feb 2nd Score:-10

i’ve never understood the obsession with jack white. he’s just a hippie who copies all the artists of the 60s. and what’s up with that pic? nobody wants to see you shaving jack.

Posted in: Stereogum Buzz Chart: Week Of 1/29/12
#3 

Ralph Jayson Silang | Jan 31st Score:-11

Instead of the sarcastic asking, why don’t you listen to his songs to know who the fuck is Bon Iver. Get it?

Posted in: Watch Bon Iver’s Grammy Commercial
#2 

Griff Fuller Jr. | Jan 30th Score:-11

Not impressed. And I’m not going to pretend like it’s cool just because a large body of other people think it’s “cool”

Posted in: Jack White – “Love Interruption”
#1  p00rtina | Jan 30th Score:-24

first dead weather/raconteurs album=quality… the second dead weather/raconteurs album=garbage.. also his production of icp…. i don’t trust jack white anymore and he is not the genius i once revered him to be..

Posted in: Jack White – “Love Interruption”

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR’S CHOICE (SCOTT)

bender bending rodriguez | Feb 1st Score:6

What they need in that band is more girls.

Posted in: Girls’ Generation Bring K-Pop To Letterman

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR’S CHOICE (AMRIT)

donnytilla | Feb 1st Score:0
uh oh I got the coffee poops lololol think i missed the point XD

 

Posted in: James Murphy Coffee Coming Soon?
 
Comments (17)
  1. There’s so many people I want to thank….Jack White’s career-gone-rogue is my first choice

  2. I’m glad to see donnytilla up here again. What a guy!

  3. Disappointed to discover I completely missed the return of rubberjohnny

  4. Rage Against Florence and the Machine

    The B-52Pacs

    Tyler, The Kreator

    Sorry, I just had to get those out of me. I literally had to.

  5. Congrats p00rtina!

  6. Man, I really miss you all. Even though I know the office firewall is going to block me out, I still click on the shortlinks in my tweet feed in hopes they’ll work.

    Feel free to send me some words. We can talk Ceremony (I hope at least one of you is going to their NYC show Saturday night), exchange memes and fill me in on some of the week’s best comments as they happen. You’ll be the Rory to my Lane on Gilmore Girls, keeping me in touch with the outside world of music despite my strict old school foreign mom’s attempts to keep me sheltered.

    • In the later series Gilmore Girls offers a pretty decent indie band / family ties narrative after Lane gets preggers and her boyfriend’s due to go on tour. It’s pretty compelling. Not that I watch it or anything

  7. And what a return for M.I.A. this week too! Well, ok, maybe the Madonna thing is not good and seeing her and Nicki Minaj as Madonna’s cheerleaders is kinda weird in a bad way, but I’m seriously loving looking at the top of the page and seeing Maya three times.
    Also, more oOoOO! Yup, this week in music is making me happy.

  8. Kind of a low scoring week ? Not sure I can offer any more intelligent analysis than that. Really lovin’ the Sharon Van Etten record tho.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.

%s1 / %s2