Take our ink-stained hands and join us at the OldStand, where Jon McMillan goes to remind everyone what an honest-to-goodness music magazine is supposed to look like.

A while back we excavated SPIN’s 8th Anniversary Dando-fest; now, through the magic of the Oldstand, we’ll slide back a year, to 1992, as SPIN attempts to dial up the seven greatest bands of all time. Well, no spoilers here. And really, nothing even remotely controversial. In ’92 Spin was still not quite as “alternative” as it would later become (or pretend to become), and their top-seven is proof positive. In no particular order:

Sex Pistols
The Beatles
The Rolling Stones
Led Zeppelin
Public Enemy
The Ramones
Jimi Hendrix

Yawn. Rolling Stone wants its canon back! Although, in fairness to SPIN, the world would not become thoroughly listified for another fifteen years (thanks for nothing, blogosphere!), so at the time this must have provoked heated arguments among the slacker set. Some of the goofy, throwaway, “seven-based” humor pieces are much more entertaining (#5 on the list of “Seven Ways To Kill A Rock Star” is “Introduce him to Jeff Lynne.” Huh?). There’s also a surprisingly prescient “Guide to College Music,” including featurettes on up-and-comers The Breeders, Manic Street Preachers, Swervedriver, Uncle Tupelo, and Moose. Well, four-out-of-five ain’t bad.

But here’s my favorite thing about this issue: buried underneath all of the self-congratulatory essays and chest-puffing argument fodder, tucked into the review section under the heading “Blue Light Special,” Jim Greer’s heartfelt defense of Queen:

What Queen did for me as a kid growing up in the suburbs in the 1970s was teach me the value of antisocial behavior. Meaning that none of my friends liked the band, but I stuck with ’em anyway (the band, not my friends)…In retrospect, it’s easy to see what [they] didn’t like. Queen was a bit off, wasn’t it? Not nearly as one-dimensional or straightforwardly rock ’n’ roll as our other heroes, Aerosmith, Boston, Sabbath, and Skynyrd, Queen introduced an element of uneasiness into the already-confusing world of adolescence, and was therefore taboo. Which to me was cool; I thought Queen was Art the way I thought The Lord of the Rings was Art. My love for the band was a way of placing myself above my peers, and of feeling misunderstood – essential for any budding misfit.

Also: NKOTB vs. Michael Jackson, TS Eliot vs. Lou Reed, and Gameboy vs. productivity.

Kim Deal on the Safari EP: “I wanted the music to go through that one machine everybody uses, to make it sound more like Phil Collins. Like a beer commercial.”

Next week: Ezra Pound vs. Prince

Hope they invested that $54mm wisely.

Headline should have read: Tetris will ruin your life.

Seven lists that make no sense.

Lars issues an unprovoked attack on REM; Cameron Crowe has seen the future of reality television, and it is vicious.

In case you care how they arrived at their conclusion.

Remember MTV? Anybody?

Jane’s Addiction = ghettoized subculture. Those were the days.

Comments (14)
  1. I knew we wouldn’t get to the end of the issue without a Studs shoutout

  2. I forgot Douglas Coupland published some of his essays in Spin-awesome.

    The juxtaposition of Lars’ R.E.M. diss against Mike Mills’ earnest social commentary is classic.

  3. I’ve never really thought about “Walk on the Wild side” before.

    it really is a dumb song.

  4. Lar’s should of answered:

    umm shit fuck, the bank statement, haha. ya.

  5. Lar’s should of answered:

    umm shit fuck, my bank statement, haha. ya.

  6. kidacomputerok  |   Posted on May 12th, 2008 0

    “Mike Hunt” looks pissed in that Breeders’ shot.

  7. Chris  |   Posted on May 13th, 2008 0

    So whose hair is that on the last page, and where on their body is it from?

  8. I just finished listening to that young singer Nasri on MYSPACE and his music is so great. He is actually behind the NKOTB comeback. He wrote the song ? click click click?, ?Close to you? and co-wrote ? summertime ? with Donnie. He also is working on some other songs with the group according to the NKOTB website. Here?s the link I found.


    My Favorite song is ?NOT THE SAME? (myspace.com/nasriworld)

    Check his myspace and add him as a friend because he always replies back with a thank you. He?s really hot too!!


  9. Wait – MTV had music at one time?

  10. fido  |   Posted on May 14th, 2008 0

    Wow. It’s weird to see that SPIN has actually improved over the years. What a worthless publication. It’s audacious enough for someone like them to do a greatest artists list, and infuriating for them to just toss it off as one of their regular columns because they’re too boringly tongue-in-cheek to do something real like that.

  11. Spin This!

  12. Llewelyn Moss  |   Posted on May 15th, 2008 0

    Nice pube on the ‘college music roundup’ scan, by the way. Well done.

  13. tummy trouble  |   Posted on Jun 21st, 2008 0

    I dunno, “clown’s playing tricks on me” is pretty funny.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.

%s1 / %s2