The ‘Gum hasn’t given much love to it, but I think that Foxygen album is the tops. Sad not to see it on this list.
1. Phosphorescent is way too low on this list (top 3 for me)
2. The David Bowie album is also a return that was way better than we had any reason to expect
3. I’m AMAZED that the Darkside album didn’t make it on this list, or any other EOY lists I’ve seen this week. That one’s been turning my mind inside out for months now
4. No Mikal?? What the deuce….
Yes! I think you nailed it, though you only gave three suggestions for spots 7-10 (that’s actually four spots).
STILL, your list is far less questionable than the one above AND basically the same as mine. If this were my list, it’d look like:
10. Last Exit
9. State of Love and Trust
8. Elderly Woman…
7. Given to Fly
6. In Hiding
5. Hail Hail
4. In My Tree
I’d personally swap Black with Love Boat Captain and In Hiding with either Porch, Do the Evolution or Whipping but we need to consider historical importance AND quality of songwriting. So yeah.
Glad to see In My Tree on here. ‘Tis my #1 fave.
Hail Hail and Elderly Woman should be on here.
And, frankly, I find it surprising that no one here’s mentioned Love Boat Captain. That’s one of their most impassioned, soul-exploding songs in their catalogue. It gets me every time.
Ditto. I think Hesitation Marks is already way underrated.
Easily the most interesting of the three HM tracks released so far. I keep coming back to it: first time, because it was a total WTF left turn. Then, after the second and third listen, I’m thinking it’s a great fracking track and who gives a shit if it doesn’t sound like anything Trent’s done in the past. Isn’t that the point???
Love it. Trent’s a grown-ass man now. He doesn’t need to be All Agro, All the Time anymore.
I can get behind this. Not Stereogum;s though.
Agreed. When I read “The hardest stories to tell…” and so on in the intro, I thought immediately of SFA. I was also thinking, last night, randomly, that Dark Days / Light Years is probably their worst…and that it’s a pretty good “worst” record to have made.
Here’s my attempt (when I should really be working):
8. Dark Days / Light Years
7. Fuzzy Logic
6. Hey Venus!
4. Phantom Power
3. Love Kraft
1. Rings Around the World
That’s not easy. Totally under-appreciated band.
Two songs, actually.
DAMMIT WHY ISN’T THIS ON THE ALBUM?!
Also, having spent a week with RAM, I’ve concluded that it’s really quite a marvelous album. Anybody else?
Your first paragraph is RIGHT on point. Kudos. It’s also worth noting that TOO MUCH of the criticism has been made after one listen. I don’t think anything can be properly judged after one listen.
The “hype” and “personal expectation” factors are huge in determining public opinion on a record. A similar thing happened with Centipede Hz (the latest example I can think of). That’s actually rewarding album. Once I laid aside the expectations of what I was HOPING for, I was able to really enjoy it. CentHz, like RAM, is rewarding if you’ll allow it to be.
As someone who’s never too much though to Daft Punk but was sorta swept up in the hype (because, really, how could ignore it??), I think the album’s pretty good. After two listens I think it’s pretty nice. I want to listen to it again, not just because it’s a pleasant listen but because people are getting so bent out of shape about it. It’s kinda fun watching people get SO invested in something they, ultimately, have nothing to do with.
Because, really, this is not your music. it’s Daft Punk’s. And Daft Punk doesn’t owe anyone anything. They play music, and if you like it, you’ll like. If not, well, you’ll move on to some other artistic to lay expectations on.
I agree with everyone commiserating about the absence of Desire LInes and Nother Ever Happened. And if I ruled the world, Lake Somerset and Wash Off would have to be on here as well.
Everything I’ve heard from this album has been kinda “Meh.” Which is really too bad. Rated R and Songs for the Deaf are STILL two of my favourite albums ever. Oh well. We always have their live show…
It’s not that I don’t like Animals (it’s a muphukkin’ CLASSIC), but this is how I imagine Stereogum’s list will look. If Piper’s not in the Top 3, it’ll be a crime against humanity.
And now we wait.
Pink Floyd’s easy (minus the soundtracks):
1) Piper at the Gates of Dawn
2) Dark Side of the Moon
3) The Wall
4) Wish You Were Here
7) Atom Heart Mother
9) The Final Cut
10) Saucerful of Secrets
11) Obscured by Clouds
12) Division Bell
14) Momentary Lapes of Reason
Can we get a Worst to Best David Bowie Album list on here? Thanks.
I’ve heard maybe three Prince songs in my life. It’s not that I don’t like him, I just haven’t been that exposed to him, nor have I had much energy to seek him out. I’m from Vancouver and was born in the ’80s. The point being that he’s not as ubiquitous in North America these days as this interviewer seems to think.
With that in mind, what’s a good album to start on? I’m clearly missing out on something.
Super Furry Animals. It would be very great to hear something from those guys again.
This probably because music is becoming more amorphous. Genres are blending more with each passing year. There is no such thing as “indie rock” any more. Any band that presents that style sound derivative of bands that were popular five years ago. This list (particularly the top 10) mirrors what North American listeners have latched on to and acknowledges where music is heading.
Thanks. But I can’t get past his voice. It’s grating and not the least bit enjoyable to listen to. But neither is mine….so whatever.
WHAT IS THE APPEAL with Cloud Nothings? I don’t get it. Someone please explain.
Why do so many people give a shit? Some talented musicians played a song together. So what? Why is this unthinkable?
“Lost” should be a classic, and maybe it will be. And “Bad Religion” is the single most heart-wrenching three minutes released this year. Yet neither seem to get enough love.
“Night of Wine and Roses” is my jam. LOVE THAT SONG. Doesn’t get nearly enough love on these year-end lists.
He’s been nominated in this category before. He won for Bone Machine waaaaaaaay back in ’92.