Agreed on Everywhere. “Night on the Sun” is one of the best songs Modest Mouse ever recorded.
Good to see “All Hands and the Cook” make the list. Originally, it wasn’t one of my favorites, but after seeing it played live, it really has an amazing energy to it. It’s clear that it’s one of the band’s favorite songs to play live.
Pretty sure The Soft Bulletin qualifies on both accounts.
Millionyoung is also very good.
I am glad Ashes Grammar made it on there at 42. Fantastic record.
Is ths list perfect? No. Is any list perfect? No. While I do think there were some albums that they missed(Frog Eyes? Menomena?), I have no problem with the top 20 and with this list. As for the whole AC v. GB thing, they’re both great. We all win.