This entire situation feels completely calculated, and this letter seems grossly insincere.
Forgive the sports metaphor, but what GoldieBlox has done here is the equivalent of the douchebags who commit an intentional foul, then immediately afterward acknowledge the foul and apologize. The apology is totally insincere, since they still got what they wanted in committing the foul. If they were truly exhibiting good sportsmanship, they wouldn’t have made the foul in the first place.
“We would like to respect his wishes and yours.” Really? Did you bother to find out what they were first?
For his entire career, Weird Al Yankovic has made a point to get the artists’ permission first before releasing a parody – DESPITE THE FACT THAT HE DOESN’T NEED TO. It’s a courtesy. If an artist says “no”, he abandons the song.
GoldieBlox could certainly have done the same. (Of course, the answer would have been “no”.)
Instead, they released something knowing there were legal questions, took legal action, screamed “Help, Help, I’m being repressed!”, and now want us to believe they didn’t mean any harm and are acting in good faith. It’s a cynical attempt to profit off of the Streisand Effect, and it’s about to work.
I want the Beasties to continue whatever legal action they had in mind (if they’ve ever intended to), if only to dissuade other companies from pulling this shit. Of course, if that happens, the next step in the GoldieBlox playbook is: “Oh, look at the big artists bullying the little company, after we apologized and everything.”
Instead, I already see Debbie high-fiving Team GoldieBlox at the end of a successful campaign.
This legend gets repeated so often, so I’ll say it again: “SAPPY” WASN’T MISIDENTIFIED. FANS DIDN’T ‘MISTAKENLY’ CALL IT THAT.
The band had already given up on the song “Verse Chorus Verse”, so Kurt reused the title for “Sappy” when it was released on No Alternative. They specifically called it “Verse Chorus Verse” in at least one interview/press release for the album.
It was only long after the fact (once “Verse Chorus Verse” from an L.A. soundcheck and the older unreleased versions of “Sappy” showed up on bootlegs) that people ‘corrected’ the song titles. But, at the time of No Alternative’s release, this was the only known version of either song – it was “Sappy”, but it was called “Verse Chorus Verse”.
Honestly, I think it may actually be mentioned in the liner of With the Lights Out. (I don’t have it in front of me, but I vaguely recall a note under “Sappy” that says “Originally released as ‘Verse Chorus Verse’.)
I don’t think Kiss makes it this year. They’ve been eligible for a while. A lot of the Hall voters hate them passionately, mainly for the crass over-marketing. (I read a story some years ago that claimed that some Hall voters were concerned that Simmons would basically make the the entire ceremony about him/them, thereby disrupting it for the other inductees.)
I think Kiss gets in eventually. But I think it’ll be either after a) a bunch of the current voters die off or b) Gene Simmons is dead.
Solid list. I held TCATS as the best Foo record for many years, but I don’t feel like it’s aged as well. I think I now may favor TNLTL.
A couple of minor observations:
1) A lot of One by One’s failure as an album has to do with the production. Grohl wanted it to echo his experience in recording Songs for the Deaf. And that’s the problem: it sounds like a QOTSA record, not a Foo Fighters record.
2) “Foo Fighters also began performing ‘Marigold’, a Nirvana song Grohl had sung, but that had never been officially released until years after Cobain’s death.”
Not exactly true – “Marigold” was officially released in 1993 on Nirvana’s “Heart-Shaped Box” single. In fairness, that single wasn’t officially released in the US – but many record stores carried it at the time. (Best Buy even carried the Nirvana singles box set in later years.) The other semantic is that “Color Pictures of a Marigold” appeared on the Simple Machines cassette (Late! Pocketwatch) that was issued in 1992.
Weirdly, “Marigold” got quite a bit of radio airplay in the late Spring of 1996 on alternative radio – once stations had burned through the obvious Foo singles.
Comparing this to mashups is absolutely ludicrous.
The Grey Album was done as an art piece. Nobody made any money off of it. Same for 99% of the mashups in existence. (Note that all of Girl Talk’s albums are free downloads.) Mashups that have been sold (legally) for profit had the permission of the sampled artists.
If Abel put this music out as “art” as a free download, you might have a reasonable argument. But Abel’s putting this out FOR PROFIT. Artists have a right to say how their work is used if it’s being used for commercial purposes. When Geoff said NO, that should have been the end of it – Abel should either have ditched the track or reworked it completely. (I doubt Geoff would have given two shits if this song had shown up in its current form on a random mixtape.)
Do a Google search for “had to work the late shift at DISH” (in quotes) and see their handiwork.
I’m not sure I understand how this is effective at all. If I’m looking into a product and want an opinion, I think the last person I want to hear from is an employee.
Kind of semantics, but this isn’t the Foo Fighters. It’s Dave Grohl, Taylor Hawkins, and what looks like (Foo Fighters and Rush producer) Nick Raskulinecz on bass.
Fixed now. Thanks!
I’ve tried several different browsers on two different machines, and I can’t get it to play. (I’m not using Flashblock.) I think there’s a problem with the filename – either the capital H or the question mark. (Probably the question mark.)
Grohl has already done pretty much the exact same thing, a thousand times better, and did it back in ’97. It’s on the Foos Greatest Hits, for crying out loud (aka, “Everlong [Acoustic]“).
One lost side note – “Down in a Hole” was placed after “Angry Chair” in the first pressings.
I was profoundly disappointed when I found out (years later) that they’d moved it up. The transition from “Angry Chair” to “Down in a Hole” was my favorite on the album, and it followed “Angry Chair” perfectly. It was a perfect coda for the album.
(Having said that, it actually made “Would?” feel even more tacked-on.)
I saw it in Toronto. Not only is this trailer the entire movie, it’s actually better edited than the actual movie. The real thing is a little bit all over the place – the Tim and Jeff storylines never really come together as they should, and there’s a totally unnecessary denouement after the concert.
Having said that, what Badgley does in the record store scene (seen briefly in the trailer) is brilliant. And he generally does a fantastic job as Buckley (with the lone exception of a scene where he and Lucas are working on something – it seemed like he was pushing himself harder than Jeff would have).
It would behoove anyone seeing this movie to familiarize yourself with Tim Buckley’s music beforehand. It focuses pretty heavily on it, and some moments are a little confusing if you aren’t familiar with it.
Despite my criticism, still worth seeing. (Though I’m hoping they take another pass at editing before its official release.)
“Breath” is one of the crossed-out songs. (The other is “In My Tree”.) I suspect they were running long.
Also, this was apparently a band-modified version of Brian’s setlist. There’s another copy floating around that has “Fatal”, “Jeremy”, and “Other Side” instead of “Severed Hand”, “Deep”, and “Nothing As It Seems”.
I’m not going to say anything about the quality/humor contained in this performance, but this was pretty scandalous live tv moment at the time, especially since MTV wasn’t running a 7-second delay for some reason.
Andrew Dice Clay – 1989 MTV Video Music Awards
Bad Religion – “Suffer” / “Walk Away”
Idaho – “Crawling Out”
Jawbreaker – “Boxcar”
Minutemen – “Political Song for Michael Jackson to Sing”
Pixies – “Tame” / “There Goes My Gun”
Sense Field – “Outlive the Man”
TMBG – “Particle Man”
I think it was on a major, but one of my favorite sub-2:00 songs is Suicide Machines’ “No Face”.
Ironically, Barry Manilow did not write “I Write the Songs”.