I think if you listen to Jonny's solo work or even Ed's old soundtrack work you'll see that that lush, orchestrated/jazzy sonic element and those ethereal synth-guitar noises respectively that are notably absent from The Eraser and Amok are their doing rather than Thom's. Ed has referenced in interviews that there actually is a slightly "rockist" member of Radiohead, but it's not him, and it's presumably not Thom or Jonny. I don't remember Ed's exact words, but it was something wonderful along the lines of "no, I'm a bit of a pothead so... I like the weird music."
What's this about all sounds and no melodies? Reverse Running (which could totally just be a Radiohead song) and Ingenue had me up out of my chair dancing and singing along the first time I heard them. I was singing the through-line of Unless at a man in the street five minutes after I got out of my car yesterday. I'm not joking when I say I've had the choruses of Default and What the Eyeballs Did stuck in my head for months. Like Lotus Flower, shit is straight-up pop, y'all mad. I love TKOL more than most (word to the wise: pepper the b-sides and non-album tracks from the period throughout, it really shines in the context of Twisted Words, Hearing Damage, Feeling Pulled Apart, Staircase, Butcher) but Amok's songs are surely more immediate.
I just really never want Yorke & co. to repudiate Kid A by going less experimental. Luckily, they don't seem to be in any danger of doing so. I wouldn't mind a little wider-screen (I'd love a Radiohead album where the string and horn at the levels of Bloom and The National Anthem ran all the way through, though In Rainbows almost has that with strings), and deployed properly (a-la The Butcher), heavily-effected guitar is still Radiohead's best secret weapon, but I'd be really disappointed if Yorke and any collaborators issued a largely guitar album at this point unless it was explicitly Twisted Words-style krautrock, or skeletal I Might Be Wrong/Reverse Running-style pieces, or exploring their slow-burn Talk Talk roots or something equally forward-thinking to his electronic stuff.
This seems like a goofy way to evaluate a group like Radiohead that seems like it puts effort into ensuring some of its essential listening isn't on its albums. Here's some alternate tracklists that might improve the standings of some of their periods, especially the two lowest-ranking ones. If you're a big Radiohead fan but consider their original tracklists sacrosanct, I'd point out that's kind of counter to their ethos (there was so much acrimony over the HTTT tracklist that Thom posted his own). Besides, they're not that different anyway.
THE KING OF LIMBS: Bloom / Morning Mr Magpie / Hearing Damage / These Are My Twisted Words / Little by Little / Feral / Feeling Pulled Apart By Horses / Lotus Flower / Codex / The Butcher / Staircase / Separator
IN RAINBOWS: 15 Step / Bodysnatchers / Nude / Weird Fishes / All I Need / Faust Arp / Reckoner / House of Cards / Down Is the New Up / Jigsaw Falling into Place / Go Slowly / Videotape / 4 Minute Warning
HAIL TO THE THIEF: 2+2=5 / Sail to the Moon / Sit down, Stand up / Backdrifts / I Am a Wicked Child / Go to Sleep / Where I End and You Begin / We Suck Young Blood / The Gloaming / Scatterbrain / There There / Paperbag Writer / Myxomatosis / A Wolf at the Door / Gagging Order
AMNESIAC: Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box / Pyramid Song / Fast-Track / You and Whose Army? / I Might Be Wrong / Trans-Atlantic Drawl / Cuttooth / Knives Out / The Amazing Sounds of Orgy / Dollars & Cents / Hunting Bears / Like Spinning Plates / Life in a Glasshouse
KID A: Great job!
OK COMPUTER: Airbag / Paranoid Android / Subterranean Homesick Alien / Exit Music for a Film / A Reminder / Karma Police / Meeting in the Aisle / Fitter Happier / Electioneering / Polyethylene, Parts 1 & 2 / Climbing up the Walls / No Surprises / Lucky / The Tourist
EARLY YEARS: Coke Babies / Creep / The Bends / Permanent Daylight / Talk Show Host / Nice Dream / Just / The Trickster / Lozenge of Love / Maquiladora / Sulk / Bishop's Robes / Blow Out
Not pretentious, interesting idea, good on him, etc. That said, people in the comments here suggesting anyone will or should learn how to play sheet music specifically for this are insane, as are people suggesting a bunch of amateur YouTube folks' covers are going to measure up to a real Beck album.
I've seen him live against my will and he is certainly a hack, but I don't think it matters what came out of his mouth after someone yells not to talk about something... it's not their damn time. It's the equivalent of interrupting a concert because you don't like the song. I don't think comedians are well-served by saying things like this that don't really contain actual jokes just for shock value, (unless what Masada said is actually what happened, because then that is a real joke) but Tosh has built a career on that. The rules that apply to conversation don't apply to comedians shutting down hecklers. I didn't think the Michael Richards thing was out of line though either. A horrible decision on his part certainly, but not telling of racism.
I think it would be a good idea for stereogum to devote a comment thread to people posting and talking about their own and each other's 2011 lists, because putting it on the comments for a post like this rightly feels like hijacking it, but errbody's got their own no-less-legitimate list and I'm as interested in the taste of fellow readers than critics from magazines I don't read.
Gus knew because in the previous episode when he was trying to kill Don Elladio Gus was acting weird and recoiled when Elladio tried to hug him. Jesse similarly was acting weird and recoiled when Gus tried to hug him, which clued him in I think. The staging was similar.
given their campiness or image-centricity or whatever you want to call it at the outset, this is like the last band I would have expected to have artistic longevity but there you go. guess the same could probably be said of blur or radiohead or many british bands that ended up being great.
Comments