I'll give them a little credit. "We Used to Wait", "White Sky" and "Everlasting Light" WERE the best songs on their respective albums, and I'm glad someone recognized it.
Alas, I don't think this will ever happen again. I could see them pulling a Portishead or a Blur & wait until 2015 for a new record, but don't hold your breath. I think they're on an amicable hiatus.
To this point, I think the lowest-rated album I've seen on a Pitchfork year-end list (that I remember, I may be wrong) was Hot Chip's "Made in the Dark", which got a 7.0 and was still in the top 25.
I'm excited for this record, and here's why: I think I'm the only person on earth who thought Proof of Youth wasn't a carbon copy of Thunder Lightning Strike. TLS had the rush of novelty (in a good way) whereas PoY was a batch of ridiculously catchy pop songs. If you did a blind listening test with a group of people who had never heard a Go! Team record, I'd bet a majority of them would prefer PoY. They are a band that by all accounts should have faded into oblivion, but I think they have the chops to make a career of it. Parton is moving away from sampling and into classic songwriting? More power to him; I hope they pull it off. High hopes for this record.
I honestly don't hear what so many people (Jim DeRogatis, for instance) heard in putting Vivian Girls in their top-5's for 2008, but this really isn't bad. Like Rob S. said, "[t]his isn't any better or worse than 90% of what's passed off as indie rock". My only caveat: would it kill them to mix the vocals just a touch higher?
Let's be honest: if the White Stripes are recording songs now, they could easily release a full-length by the end of summer. It could be coming out next week, for all we know.
2569 Most Anticipated Albums Of 20102569 Most Anticipated Albums Of 2010