Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

R.I.P. to one of the greats, Thomas Earl Petty. Here I asked several dozen artists to share their favorite Tom Petty song. A few got back to me after deadline, and here’s one of those…

“Room At The Top” is one of our favorites. The song is from his record Echo that he released with the Heartbreakers in ’99. I remember hearing that song for the first time and thinking how sad it was. Every time I’d go to see him play I secretly hoped he would play it, but he never did. I’ve heard he’s only played it live a handful of times because the song is too dark for him. The opening line — “I’ve got a room at the top of the world tonight” — paints such a wild picture. “I got a room where everyone, can have a drink and forget those things that went wrong in their life.” So heartbreaking. It gets even better when it kicks into the chorus and the chords change. He still uses the same lyric from the verse — “I got a room at the top of the world tonight” — with that super percussive cadence he does, hanging on one note. He sings that line over and over again until the final line “and I ain’t comin dowwwn.” That’s that fist in the air shit he did so well.
– Danielle Haim

Your best and worst comments from an incredibly shitty week are below.


#9  blochead
Score:27 | Oct 2nd

So I was in the US Navy from 1986-1990. And served on a relatively small ship for most of that time. And what we listened to out to sea was a huge deal. The black dudes wanted to listen to R&B and the white dudes wanted to listen to classic rock. Tom Petty was the one artist that we invariably settled on as some kind of “middle ground” (even tho it really wasn’t)

To this day if you are at an outdoor event with a bunch of middle aged people Tom Petty’s Greatest Hits album is THE one to spin. Everybody knows all those songs. And with good reason. They are all fucking great.

I’m not taking this one well.

Posted in: Tom Petty Dead At 66
#8  kvlt of blake
Score:27 | Oct 4th

Do not tempt 2017.

Posted in: Bhad Bhabie Is The Teenage Rap Star We Deserve
#7  blochead
Score:28 | Oct 4th

All you need to know about Tom Petty is 74 artists commented on their personal favorite by him and NOT ONE picked “Breakdown” An absolutely fucking masterpiece of a song that virtually everybody knows. Simply amazing article.

Posted in: 74 Artists On Their Favorite Tom Petty Song
#6  blochead
Score:28 | Oct 2nd

For me the worst part of this is how numb I am to it. I want to be as shocked and outraged as anybody else but if I’m being honest I’m just dead to it. I open up Yahoo! read the absolutely staggering numbers of dead and injured and think “That’s just awful. Do the Sox start on weds or thurs?” I’m not being flippant, callous, or grandstanding here. I’m simply dead inside to even the most horrific atrocities at this point. And not being more upset by something this vile makes me question everything. About the world and myself. And I hate it.

Posted in: Las Vegas Country Festival Shooting Leaves At Least 59 Dead, Hundreds Injured In Largest Mass Shooting In US History
#4  undergroundspoon
Score:31 | Oct 2nd

Still one of the most underrated albums of the 2010s.

Posted in: Oracular Spectacular Turns 10
#3  cokeparty
Score:37 | Oct 2nd

Tom Petty doesn’t get a lot of the gushing critical adoration Dylan or The Beatles get, possibly because he never seemed to care about recording a big concept album or writing lyrics that nodded to surrealism or ambiguous profundity, but, what he did do well, as well as anyone that picked up guitar, was write air tight songs that sounded like classics from the first minute you heard them. Songs that just seemed to always be there. I bet if you ask the guys, mentioned above, who are still alive, they’d tell you how impossible that trick is to pull off. Petty did that shit in his sleep. This day is testing my resolve. Gonna listen to You Got Lucky and remember I did.

Posted in: Tom Petty Dead At 66
#2  blochead
Score:40 | Sep 29th

WOW. This is impressive. Whoever made this did a pretty nice job.

Posted in: Taylor Swift Loves The National, Dum Dum Girls, & Cigarettes After Sex


#5  wg
Score:-10 | Oct 2nd

Ya know, 75% of gun homicide in the US is committed with handguns (ie. sidearms as you say) – not assault rifles – and the vast majority of gun related homicide occurs in inner cities, right?

But, but, but, nobody wants to focus on statistical reality – just sensational 24/7 cable news events that reinforce their skewed political biases and irrational fears.

Posted in: Las Vegas Country Festival Shooting Leaves At Least 59 Dead, Hundreds Injured In Largest Mass Shooting In US History
#4  FredBob
Score:-10 | Oct 3rd

Come on Annie… you can’t have it both ways.
Ok, abstract sterility of the cosmestic surgery as a metaphor for wants and desires out of control made art?
You’ve made the deals, cash flow projections are made before the ink dries and its being compressed and sold back to us? Or should this be consumed in the shadow of today’s 24 hour ‘Everything Now’ culture as not quite mindless fun, but you might as well wink knowingly while the cart is dragged to hell?? Give your fans more credit.

Posted in: St. Vincent – “Los Ageless” Video
#3  FredBob
Score:-11 | Oct 3rd

I think St Vincent is sold to you as “Great Art” in the same way Kanye West is the “Greatest Rapper”… More an ‘art as aesthetic’ compartmentalised claim than anything. Surely you as a surveyor of great art, you know it is in the eye of the beholder and the meaning we attach to it? That great art bursts through the context it is created through, rendering context just a means for surveyor to make some rational sense of this work that has struck them in some profound way?

I dont believe St Vincent’s presentation here, because Annie is becoming bigger than the St Vincent persona…. she was much braver in personal themes of the first albums rather than the brash larger themes of recent work.

Posted in: St. Vincent – “Los Ageless” Video
#2  ImConfused69
Score:-13 | Oct 3rd

Wait, Chris.

Aren’t you the guy who called Ben and Andrew “studio-rats” and their music “shit”?

Will never be able to take you seriously dude, and honestly, surprised you still have a job with such stale writing.

Posted in: Oracular Spectacular Turns 10
#1  jimvrountree
Score:-27 | Oct 2nd

neither one of those albums came out in 95

Posted in: Tom Petty Dead At 66



Darren Frye
Score:20 | Oct 2nd

The summer of ’95 was all about two albums: Petty’s Wildflowers and the Black Crowes Amorica. I had just graduated college and was working for a radio station on Long Island. I was in promotions and was supposed to, uh, promote the station everywhere I went. Instead, I’d drive all over the Northern State and LIE – back and forth, up and down – until I got bored. I’d often drive out to the Hamptons, pull that big ass ugly yellow vanimal up to the beach and blast Petty out of the back through the massive speakers held within. Once I got into a fight with the other big classic rock station by plastering their van with my station’s bumper stickers while at the Mattituck Strawberry Festival. That might be the whitest sentence ever. Man what a great summer that was. Haven’t really thought about it in quite some time. RIP Tom Petty.

Posted in: Tom Petty Dead At 66