Premature Evaluation – Band Of Horses Cease To Begin

We called Band Of Horses’ follow-up to Everything All The Time “very pretty, but very slight.” Our readers are divided: Some think it’s “shitty,” “boring and sappy,” while others call it “a really great record” and a sign of the band’s maturity. Our favorite suggestion? “Needs more reverb.” At least everyone agreed that naming a song “Detlef Schrempf” is pretty cool.