Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

Did you guys have a good Radiohead week? (Is every week Radiohead week?) Congrats to Alec Baldwin, Stephen Colbert, and Corban who all got to bask in their presence. Better luck next time, Wall Street. In non-Radiohead news, this weekend Stereogum will be at ATP: I’ll Be Your Mirror, curated by Portishead: follow us on Twitter and we’ll let you know if spot Thom Yorke. Or The Duchess Of Thom Yorke.



Don Osborn | Sep 27th Score:12

I am not embarrassed about my love for the Reminder. That is a truly wonderful record. Who the fuck cares that other people also liked it? I learned to get over that shit 20 years ago when everyone started liking other records that I liked “first,” i.e. Nevermind, Blood Sugar Sex Magik, Ten, etc. Come on Stereogum; you can grow up too. If “same people who liked The Reminder will probably like this one” then I am looking forward it. cheers.

Posted in: Feist Metals Premature Evaluation
#9 memoryboy | Sep 24th Score:12

It’s great to see Michael Robenalt cement himself as the number one commenter in Stereogum, although after two strong releases he will have to hold off other top-tier acts like MikeyObviously, djfreshie and Conor Johnson, all of whom have highly anticipated comments expected soon.

The wildly uneven Michael_ is struggling to find his niche, while hyped newcomer The Aura of the H-Man will want to deliver on his sophomore effort.

Finally, fans continue to wait for the comeback of immensely popular comment pioneer Chris Trash.

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

Tucker Tracy Umbehagen | Sep 29th Score:13

“If I Did It”

Posted in: What Should Courtney Love Title Her Memoir?
#7 Scott | Sep 29th Score:13

Respectfully disagree with Tom on one point: I could listen to “Hey Ya” every day forever.

Posted in: VH1 100 Greatest Songs Of The ’00s

Colin Snider | Sep 26th Score:14

Nevermind that shit – is Lou Reed actually wearing SHORTS in that photo?

Posted in: Lou Reed & Metallica – “The View”

Wesley Gentle | Sep 25th Score:18

Gandhi blows, that guy hasn’t done shit in decades.

Posted in: Watch Radiohead On Saturday Night Live

Matt Roach | Sep 23rd Score:19

Any black-and-white videos out this week?

Posted in: The 5 Best Videos Of The Week
#3 Dr. Feelgood | Sep 29th Score:20

VH1 takes their lists very seriously.

Posted in: VH1 100 Greatest Songs Of The ’00s
#2 amrit | Sep 28th Score:21

More like “Freak On A Yeeeesh” who’s with me

Posted in: Korn Go Dubstep, Finally
#1 middledistancebummer | Sep 26th Score:25

at least they found a way to stop people from downloading their music.

Posted in: Lou Reed & Metallica – “The View”



Evan Fox | Sep 23rd Score:-5

Stereogum, let’s stay away from the ‘filler’ articles, hmm? What’s next – pictures of indie rockers picking up their pet’s poo? Can’t wait!

Posted in: Five Indie Types Who Would Do Well On X Factor… And Five Who Wouldn’t

Bojan Cimbaljevi? | Sep 27th Score:-6

I seriously doubt that anyone of you guys have ever been in the same room with a copy of Ride the Lightning, let alone listened to a single song off it, yet you have the audacity to trash Metallica, that’s puny and lame. They fuckin’ rock, and you might as well continue listening to Lady Gaga and the likes and stay the fuck away.

Posted in: Lou Reed & Metallica – “The View”

Kable Segriff | Sep 25th Score:-9

Radiohead blows, haven’t done anything good in years.

Posted in: Watch Radiohead On Saturday Night Live

Taylor Adams | Sep 27th Score:-10

uhh, did thom have like a stroke or something? whats wrong with the left side of his face?

Posted in: Watch Radiohead On The Colbert Report
#1 Michael_ | Sep 27th Score:-10

noun \?sär-?ka-z?m\
Definition of SARCASM
1: a sharp and often satirical or ironic utterance designed to cut or give pain
2 a : a mode of satirical wit depending for its effect on bitter, caustic, and often ironic language that is usually directed against an individual b : the use or language of sarcasm

Posted in: Feist Metals Premature Evaluation


Dan Wood | Sep 29th Score:2

What’s next? Chino Morena doing a Witch House album? Oh wait…

Posted in: Korn Go Dubstep, Finally


Erin Joe Hotovy | Sep 27th Score:2

Completely irrelevant without the Replacements

Posted in: Rock Hall 2012 Nominees: GN’R, Cure, RHCP, Beasties