Reed Kurtz

Comments from Reed Kurtz

Born to Hula and If Only Everything are both top 10 for me. All this talk is telling me I really need to listen to more current QOTSA!
+1 |
August 31, 2017 on The 10 Best Queens Of The Stone Age Songs
"In the Fade" is the other one
+4 |
August 31, 2017 on The 10 Best Queens Of The Stone Age Songs
My first thought as soon as I saw this list: "C-c-c-c-cocaine!!!"
+1 |
August 31, 2017 on The 10 Best Queens Of The Stone Age Songs
That's great to hear, thanks for sharing! FWIW I do think Stereogum has really grown into a very warm and welcoming commenting community in the time I've been lurking here (going on 6 or 7 years at least), which really sets it apart from other music sites I've followed over the years. I don't think this has anything to do w/ _'s departure in any way, just more of an observation that if he were to choose to return, I think he would find it conducive to maintaining good vibes. I really missed _ after he left, I thought he had a lot of really sharp observations (amid a lot of negativity which I'm glad to see he's achieved progress in dealing with).
+4 |
August 11, 2017 on Fiona Apple Shares Video Message For Sinéad O’Connor: “You Are My Hero”
FWIW I think the best books that replicate this experience but still maintain some semblence of a coherent plot are David Mitchell's "Cloud Atlas" (just saw the movie btw, the book is a gazillion times more enjoyable) and Italo Calvino's "If On a Winter's Night a Traveler" (which is an absolute must for anyone who enjoys modernist/post-modern literature)
+1 |
August 11, 2017 on Here’s The Album Artwork For LCD Soundsystem’s American Dream
I'm a week late to this thread but my strategy for reading big sprawling books like Infinite Jest (and probably Pynchon too though I like most people here couldn't get into "Gravity's Rainbow" - I also don't even remember anything from "Inherent Vice" the movie, but that was either because I was too stoned and/or fell asleep) is to just plow through as hard and fast as you can (which takes a decent amount of dedication and free time). When I read Infinite Jest I told myself I was gonna finish it in a month, and I did (IIRC it was May 2012 or 2011) and absolutely loved every minute of it.
+1 |
August 11, 2017 on Here’s The Album Artwork For LCD Soundsystem’s American Dream
bingo. I miss the days when you could download mp3s from soundcloud (is that still possible or is it just up to the artists themselves to make it available or not?)
+1 |
August 11, 2017 on SoundCloud Accepts $170 Million Rescue, Taps New CEO
cokeparty I think this is at least the second time I've logged in just to upvote you
+4 |
August 11, 2017 on Fiona Apple Shares Video Message For Sinéad O’Connor: “You Are My Hero”
Night Time, My Time is one of my favorite albums of the 2010s and IMHO is if not as good, is at least on a plane comparable to that of Art Angels. (I at least enjoy both albums about equally). Grimes of course had her own issues with delays and such in the process of making that masterpiece. Here's to hoping Sky's followup is similarly comparable to Ms. Boucher's when all is said and done! All good things come in time.
+5 |
July 17, 2017 on Sky Ferreira Shares Update On New Music
Kurt Vile, Adam Granduciel/War on Drugs, ... yeah that'd be pretty dope!
+5 |
July 14, 2017 on Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments
Man between this and "For Emma, Forever Ago" this is a gaggle of indie rock riches this week. Ga^5 is like the Platonic ideal of an indie rock record: so many catchy singles that went great on my playlists from the time and which could go on in the car or at a party, nice punchy length (10 songs, 37 minutes), nice cover art. This was my first real engagement with the band which means it will always be my favorite album of theirs, even if I probably like some other individual tracks better ("Everything Hits at Once" is amazing).
+2 |
July 10, 2017 on Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga Turns 10
Such a great album, basically the pinnacle of what this kind of wispy, acoustic, singer-songwriter type of music captures for me. It's the type of music that makes you feel nostalgic the first time you hear it, like most instant classics do. Personally I can look back on this album as something of a shift or growth or evolution in my own taste in music, from regularly listening to Jack Johnson and DMB and such to a more constant desire to seek out more heady and emotionally and spiritually satisfying music. (Nothing against those artists but you know what I mean!) Great music captures ideas and emotions better than any words alone can do, and this album does that. Nostalgic, romantic, dark and ruminant yet hopeful, it is a sublime achievement.
0 |
July 10, 2017 on For Emma, Forever Ago Turns 10
I logged in just to upvote this. Now that I'm here, worth mentioning that The Shepherd's Dog turns 10 in September(!).
0 |
July 10, 2017 on For Emma, Forever Ago Turns 10
"Mistaken for Strangers" is easily one of my favorite songs of all time, and IMHO one of the greatest songs of 2000s, as is this album which will forever mark a musically-defined period of my life ie Sophomore-Junior years of college. I also had the tremendous fortune of seeing them do a relatively small tent show the Thursday night at Bonnaroo 2007, which I attended with my brother. We lit and passed a joint back and forth as the show started, which they opened with "Start a War," and out of the corner of my eye I watched my brother appear to levitate as the music crescendoed, so enraptured he was with the music, and once the song ended and the notes cut out, my brother was so taken with the music that he collapsed to the ground as the song ended! I helped him up and we made our way to the edge of the tent to watch the rest of the show (the next song, of course, was Mistaken for Strangers) and of course my brother didn't remember anything of what had just happened (he was perfectly fine btw). I've never gotten into the rest of their stuff as much as I did Boxer and Alligator but The National will always hold a special place in my heart.
+4 |
May 22, 2017 on Boxer Turns 10
Wow I am so happy to have rediscovered this. The music video to "Make It Better" is absolutely fantastic.
0 |
May 15, 2017 on Artist To Watch: Hazel English
This is exactly what I meant. Besides "Crush" (which I think is an amazing song, full stop) and a handful of other stuff I enjoyed at the time (when I was also digging Dispatch, Jack Johnson, and other stuff just before I really got into "indie music"), my main experiences with DMB were tagging along to concerts with friends who were way more into them than I was and having a good time hanging out and enjoying the vibes.
0 |
May 12, 2017 on “King Of Festivals” Dave Matthews Explains Why Fyre Fest Was One Of The Greatest Things That’s Ever Happened
I don't think it's accurate to characterize this situation as "2 days from allegation to complete banishment and ruin." First, I think it's telling how quickly a lot of the touring bands and others associated with Ben and the band have distanced themselves and/or issued statements that basically corroborate details that have emerged, which suggests that there is more than just flimsy allegations. Second, and perhaps more importantly, if we take the accuser at their word (which so far we don't have reason not to), this is an issue that dates much farther back than just 2 days ago - it's only been two days that its been "public." Third, this story is far from over, and it's not as if we quite have "banishment and ruin" yet. Conner and Isaac in fact seem like pretty clear-cut examples of how people can maintain their career in spite of pretty horrible allegations. And if it is in fact the case that Ben is guilty of abuse (and other related issues like covering it up), far be it from me to say that this is an irredeemable crime, ie I don't think this should be the end for them per se, but rather we do need a long, hard dialogue about how to deal with these sorts of things, as fellow music lovers, human beings, and part of a broader community.
+2 |
May 12, 2017 on Details Of Alleged Assault By PWR BTTM’s Ben Hopkins Emerge
Totally agree. This law seems like an overly punitive way of addressing a serious social harm (which coming from the land of Joe Arpaio doesn't surprise me in the least), and yet aiding and abetting consumers of child porn isn't exactly working towards the long arc of justice.
+1 |
May 11, 2017 on Country Radio Station Pulls PSA Giving Tips On How To Hide Child Porn. Really.
When is Dave Matthews and Band going to get their critical re-appraisal/re-valuation from the indie community, especially now that jam bands appear to be back in vogue (see: recent articles on the Grateful Dead)? Note that I'm not necessarily saying they deserve vindication (I'm personally kinda neutral, maybe ambivalent on the matter), but just wondering how long it takes til we get a "30 essential DMB songs" from the 'Gum.
+3 |
May 11, 2017 on “King Of Festivals” Dave Matthews Explains Why Fyre Fest Was One Of The Greatest Things That’s Ever Happened
I knew it! Man I learned so much stuff off that site back in the day. It's still great, but man the wormholes and discussions back then... Like one of Borges's libraries, but for metal geeks
+1 |
May 1, 2017 on The Black Market: The Month In Metal – April 2017
Is Helm from Locust Leaves the same Helm who was a commenter on Invisible Oranges like back when Cosmo was editor (like circa 2009)? I remember that dude had an absolutely encyclopedic knowledge of metal and pretty sure was Greek too
+2 |
April 28, 2017 on The Black Market: The Month In Metal – April 2017
time flies when you're having fun
+4 |
April 23, 2017 on “Chocolate Rain” Came Out 10 Years Ago
quick thoughts (currently on 3rd listen): good kid will always (probably) be my favorite album of his, just b/c it was his breakout for me and it has so many immediate bangers. (TPAB is probably the 'greater' album, but has less replayability for me, and untitled well is amazing but in a league of its own.) This one though combines everything that was great about gkmc and Buttlerfly: it bangs, it is heady, very conceptual, and has a ton of immediate impact as well as reveals layers upon layers on multiple listens. He's still dealing with the same issues on Butterfly, after all, and assumes even more of the meta/self-reflective element of the artist. It may very well go down as his best, it is an incredible achievement.
+3 |
April 14, 2017 on Premature Evaluation: Kendrick Lamar DAMN.
Woods is so consistently good. I still come around to "Songs of Shame" about as much as any album that I caught in 2009 (that's saying something).
+3 |
April 11, 2017 on Woods – “Bleeding Blue”
Oh man, I knew that I had to recognize this song, even though I had no idea what it actually sounded like. Turns out the Butler University pep band plays this at every home game, typically late in the game during the second half TV timeout! Great song, sounds even better played by a live band in front of sold-out crowd in a tight game.
0 |
January 31, 2017 on “The Impression That I Get” Turns 20
Krallice never fail to disappoint. With Burial, I've been loving getting accustomed to these year-end drops that consistently blow my mind (and best-of lists).
+1 |
December 21, 2016 on Stream Krallice Prelapsarian
NPR fwiw I think has been repping metal for a while now - Lars Gotrich has always premiered great stuff, and he appears on other weekly podcasts pretty regularly (at least he did when I was a more consistent follower of NPR Music). But I def agree with the general point that there's a lot out there going in the right direction for metal right now - maybe I'm biased but I think there's never been a better time to be a metal fan, nor is there any other genre of music deeper, richer, or more exciting than contemporary metal right now.
0 |
December 15, 2016 on The 40 Best Metal Albums Of 2016
I also lived in Chile (Valpo tb precisamente) from 2010-2013 and it was through Stereogum (and Invisible Oranges, and Pitchfork and NPR Music) that kept me connected with the music scene in the US. The online community here (and on the metal side of things, at Invisible Oranges at the time) which helped me keep grounded and provided compansionship during some of the times of social isolation that can come with living abroad. Some concert highlights during that time: Tortoise at the the Teatro Municipal in Stgo; Bomba Estereo, The Walkmen, and Dinosaur Jr at the Primavera Fauna festival; and Roger Waters performing "The Wall" at the Estadio Nacional. Oh and watching Faith No More perform on TV during the Teleton, it's crazy how popular they are down there! Plus tons of great live local bands and peñas in Valpo.
+2 |
December 2, 2016 on The 50 Best Albums Of 2016
This was a great write-up, thanks so much for sharing (made me think back to some great Invisible Oranges articles back in the day). I was just reflecting on how these apocalyptic times we're living in are creating some great art, especially in the realm of music. Anohni's "Hopelessness" (decidedly not a metal album) is a serious AOTY contender. Last year alone had Locrian's "Return to Annihilation," Cattle Decap's "Anthropocene Extinction" and Mgla's "Exercises in Futility." Definitely looking forward to more explicitly political heavy music to come out in the near future - even as I fear what comes with Trump (and his ilk).
+2 |
November 30, 2016 on The Black Market: The Month In Metal – November 2016
"No Trump, No KKK, No Fascist USA" is not just an homage to 80s punk, it's also a common chant at recent anti-Trump rallies I've been to - much like "Alright" became an anthem of Black Live Matters protests
+11 |
November 21, 2016 on Watch Green Day Chant “No Trump! No KKK! No Fascist USA!” From The AMAs Stage