After five years of dating, Andy Samberg and Joanna Newsom are now married. The couple’s wedding took place yesterday at a luxury retreat in Big Sur, the Post Ranch Inn, according to US Weekly. “He liked her music and would go to her shows,” a friend of Samberg’s said in an interview with the magazine. “He had the biggest crush on her.” In an interview for Glamour‘s September issue, Samberg said: “We’ve talked about [collaborating]. But we’ve decided ultimately that her fans would probably kill me in my sleep … What she does is so, like, actually beautiful and important.” Check out some photos of the couple through the years here.