Christianity And The Cold War Kids Backlash

Christianity And The Cold War Kids Backlash

By now, you not only know of the soul-clapping yelp-rock of Cold War Kids, you even know they met at the Bible Institute of Los Angeles; that’s how far the gospel (pun) of the band has spread. The San Diego CityBEAT’s cover story this week traces the rapid rise of — and backlash against — the band, identifying the vitriolic pressure point (their faith) and the trigger man (Pitchfork). They write (via Cat Dirt Sez):

After revealing their time at [Bible Institute Of Los Angeles], it seemed recognizing Cold War Kids’ talent was secondary to having a loud opinion about them. Worse, they were pigeonholed as a “Christian band.”

It started with the influential, naysaying indie-rock website, Pitchforkmedia.com. The site’s initial blurbs about the Kids were mostly either cheeky or just downright negative. A review of their song “Hospital Beds” proclaimed that Willett’s “pompous delivery makes every song sound like a Jeff Buckley cover band playing a wedding drunk.”

Of their South-by-Southwest performance, Pitchfork reported that “the skinny-jeaned Christians of Cold War Kids staggered around a bit, their singer coming off like an embittered Taylor Hicks.”

Things didn’t change with the review of Robbers & Cowards. Writer Marc Hogan, as if hit by a lightning bolt from the bitter gods of music journalism, interpreted Willett’s lyrics as reverent proclamations. At one point, he even compared them to George W. Bush’s genuflecting speeches.

Although Robbers & Cowards is filled with religious imagery–often sung from the perspective of a fictional character–Willett says context has been completely ignored in such reviews.

“It’s just lazy journalism, where if you don’t like a band, you pick up one thing about them and say, ‘I’m gonna write about this.'”

Guitarist Russell, whose father is in fact an Evangelical preacher, agrees: “That seems to be the agenda; not to have a thoughtful reflection on music but to have a sharp angle and a funny way of saying it.”

Doesn’t seem like the Kids’ Christianity is a legit criticism in this case; just a convenient handle for insult. Or, did Jesus push you off the bandwagon? Does CWK’s devotion get in your way more than Sufjan’s? Jeremy Enigk’s? Also, Matisyahu = total heeb … Gotta a problem with that, Schreiber?

    Hi. It looks like you're using an ad blocker.

    As an independent website, we rely on our measly advertising income to keep the lights on. Our ads are not too obtrusive, promise. Would you please disable adblock?