Last night, the Killers partook in some holiday celebrations on Jimmy Kimmel for the second year in a row, bringing their Christmas-original-a-year tradition to a wider audience. They played the video for their single this year, “Dirt Sledding,” and played their single from last year, “Joel, The Lump Of Coal,” live. That’s the one that apparently Kimmel himself had a hand in co-writing! The host also makes a quick cameo in the song as Santa. You can watch the performance below.