
|
Alex Manning
Website:
-
|
Comments
I feel like if they were going to obviously rip off the song, they could have at least tried to add the same emotion when they say “I will watch over you”. The above just sounds like a boring cover of the original. On the other hand, the commercial is pretty moving with the song.
Haighters gonna Haight
To be honest, I was kinda sad that I See A Darkness was changed to 4/4 time, and the tone was changed so dramatically. It used to be such a perfect song, and now I feel it has lost a lot of the original feeling that made it so heart breaking.
So I really hope they do this during Outside Lands. Either way, I always wonder how bands feel about playing their older songs. Imagine if your fans could not give a damn about anything you have done since 1991. I remember reading about how much Kurt Cobain hated playing Smells Like Teen Spirit every night, and can only imagine what that is like over a period of 20+ years.
Upvote him to 0. All he is trying to do is get the lowest rating each week.
I just read about this, it is pretty sad, but expected. Rolling Stone mentioned that he was too sick to go to their inauguration into the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame, and was also the reason they got actors to play them in their last music video. Still heart breaking.
http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/beastie-boys-co-founder-adam-yauch-dead-at-48-20120504
No Outside Lands? Maybe I am biased because I live in SF, but I am ridiculously excited by their lineup this year.
Oh nevermind, this was last years line up. Sadness, sadness all around
Holy shit, thanks for telling me about this festival. How can you seriously say no to Girls, No Age, The Weakerthans, Japandroids, Ty Segall, Strange Boys, Olivia Tremor Control, Explosions in the Sky, OFF!. Definitely considering the 5 hours drive for this.
I really believe Cass McCombs can do no wrong. This is such an amazing song, and I love how reminiscent of political folk from the 60s. Although indie folk really hit its stride (as in it became ridiculously popular) in 2007 and 2008, I hope the political folk movement can come back.
The band is amazing (one of my favorite to live bands), however I was really disappointed with Be the Void. Although it is not a bad album, it only has a few really great songs. I felt that Shame Shame was just leagues ahead of Be the Void. With that said, I am absurdly excited to see them again at Outside Lands
While looking through the collection, I could not help thinking about how Thomas Jefferson’s book collection was so large, that after the Library of Congress burned down in 1815, he sold 6,500 books to them for replacements, some of which are still used today: Jefferson’s two-volume 1764 edition of the Quran was used by Rep. Keith Ellison for his swearing in to the House of Representatives.
Although I assume the Library of Congress has most, if not all, of these records, I am always amazed how extensive these personal collections are, and what will happen to them after Peel passes.
The navigation on the website is amazing, and the details regarding the album are amazing (pictures of the front, back, and inside sleeve. The only thing I could ask for is a picture of the record itself, and I cannot give a compelling reason for why, I just want to see it out there…..
It’s better to burn out than to fade away?
Part of me is ridiculously excited by this, but another part does not want it to happen, and keep the mysticism of Loveless alive.
Is it sad that I found all of those comments funny.
Michael is at least interesting, I seriously read through all of his long rants, because they are well written. RubberJohnny is predictable and boring, like most trolls. I would take Michael on a tantrum any day of the week over RubberJohnny.
This is definitely a grower of an album. To be honest, I (who knows little about metal) feel the album is not original enough to truly astound me, and has nothing truly original enough that I could differentiate it from other albums made in 1995. Sure I can here the CoC influences (it does remind me of Wise Blood), but feel that the mastering of the album takes away from any of truly genius moments, having drowned out all of the instruments, or maybe Spotify’s just low quality….. Either way, based on my first listen, I just do not feel like this bring enough to the table to truly differentiate it from so many other metal albums out there.
Unless it is this 8 year old, since she kinda kicks ass:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?&v=uU6U-8LP1DY
I guess I can agree with the “no such thing as a true cover” to an extent, however there is no question that there are original takes on covers, and those that feel like covering artist is not contributing. A great example of this would be Jimi Hendrix’ version of “All Along The Watchtower” or even remixes, such as Wise Blood’s version of “Someday”. To be honest, even Rod Stewart’s version of “Downtown Trains” was exceptional given that he changed the feel of the song. There are also cases where nothing has changed song wise, except the singer, and even then, the difference is so small, the cover feels flat.
Sadly, a number of artist do not have control over who get’s permission to cover their track (the record company does). Even those that do have a right to be disappointed by the outcome. Think about it this way, Gotye could have been expecting something more original or a completely different take, something Glee has done many times in the past.
I can agree that a cover is not meant to be a carbon copy, however many do come off that way, and when they sound close enough, but off, I imagine it can be very frustrating for the original artist. I do not know the Glee version, so I cannot judge in this case, but I do know many artists have their singles ruined by someone singing the song as close to possible. I do not know how The Who felt when Fred Durst sung “Behind Blue Eyes” but I cannot imagine they were all that impressed; it sounded more like a poor karaoke version of the song than a true cover.
Edit: I just listened to this version, and although not bad, it does not feel like a real cover. Although I do not like the version so much, Glee’s “I Want to Hold Your Hand” was more of a cover, given it was an original take, than this.
I can respect Gotye in this case. He is not complaining about Glee in general, but rather how they performed his song, believing that they did not do it justice. Although it may have propelled the single, it is not wrong to wish that the best version of the song was put forth. I know many musicians get pissed off when the radio fucks up the EQ on their songs, even though they are getting free publicity, so I can only imagine how someone would feel when their biggest hit is “ruined” in front of a wide audience.
Hands down my favorite fan letter regarding the Desaparecidos:
http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/2288-read-music-speak-spanish/
Although far from the best, Heavy Metal Drummer makes me ridiculously happy every time I hear it. Radio Cure is my favorite, every time I hear the line “Oh, distance has no way of making love understandable” breaks me heart.
This is amazing. Between this and “Looking for a Sign”, I am really happy that Beck is going back to the Sea Change-esque folk and blues.



































Simple Song should have been higher on the list, that video is just fantastic. Also, (as a Jew) I had higher expectations for HYFR, but maybe that is just bitter jealousy that my Bar Mitzvah was not nearly as cool.