Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best Comments

Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best Comments

You’re the world’s best music blog community and I know that some of you miss the downvote feature our old comments section had. We intentionally disabled downvoting with the new toolset, but I said we would consider bringing it back if I remembered to run a poll today.

A few things to note… I don’t believe OpenWeb has the “hide a comment with x downvotes” functionality, so you will still see unpopular comments. Hateful comments have to be flagged by at least two people to get kicked into the moderation queue. (If James or I see anyone with a lot of moderated comments week after week we will ban the account.) And if we do decide to bring back downvotes, I have no idea how long it will take OpenWeb to enable that. Also! If the results of this poll are close, we may decide not to take any action on the decision right now.

So, here ya go: What is the song of the summer? I mean, should we bring back downvotes?


THIS WEEK’S 10 HIGHEST RATED COMMENTS

#10 
Justice
Score: 25 | Jul 25th

Looks like I might be the cheese that stands alone on this one, but I just love Heartbreaker. I’m always here for Fun Mariah, and this is as fun as she gets.
And I really dug Jay-Z’s verse. I was, and still am, square enough that drug dealing and N-word packed rap is not for me, but I’d loved Can I Get A… and Hard Knock Life, and I think Big Pimpin is a 9 or 10. He’s absurdly charismatic. And I love the way he says “middo of the night” and “skeeoos”. (Although even I didn’t need the video to define what a skeeo was!)
To me, this was Mariah doing Britney. And not just by displaying her insanely toned midriff in those jeans with the waistband cut off. She added more vocal fry to her delivery. And I really love the roller coaster effect she gets by going loud at the beginning of some of the lines and then sitting on her vocal until right near the end, teasing us with her full vocal pyro.
This is 10/10 for me.

Posted in: The Number Ones: Mariah Carey’s “Heartbreaker” (Feat. Jay-Z)
#9 
Captain Bee Fart
Score: 26 | Jul 26th

I believe they were known as Viet Cong

Posted in: Preoccupations – “Death Of Melody”
#8 
Legeis
Score: 31 | Jul 27th

This is the 4th consecutive #1 song with a one word title.
It’s the longest streak so far.

Bailamos, Unpretty, Heartbreaker, smooth

Posted in: The Number Ones: Santana’s “Smooth” (Feat. Rob Thomas)
#7 
HiveIslet
Score: 32 | Jul 28th

Kelis’s milkshake may bring all the boys to the yard, but Beyonce has a really long straw that stretches acroooooss the room. To drink it.

Posted in: Kelis Says She Was Sampled On Beyoncé’s New Album Without Her Permission
#6 
64percentmice
Score: 32 | Jul 25th

“prices and formats are consistent with industry standards for top performers.”

YOU ARE THE INDUSTRY, YOU DEFINE THE STANDARD

Posted in: Ticketmaster Defends Bruce Springsteen Ticket Prices That Reached $5,000
#5 
Gui Velasquez
Score: 32 | Jul 22nd

long time reader, first time commenter.

I’ve always found Tom’s writing in TNO’s impressive, inspiring, beautiful, funny, insightful, but this might be the first column that has quite literally driven my tears. Perhaps that’s due to the fact that I’m also dealing with health issues and just came home from the hospital today, so I can totally relate to how T-Boz felt in that hotel room writing the lyrics to “Unpretty.”

TLC for me was a formative group. I absolutely adored them from the jump, which for me was “Baby Baby Baby.” I will always associate the summer of 1995 with memories of being in the back of my grandma’s car on our way to the pool, competing with my cousins on who could do a better job of mimicking Left Eye’s rap in “Waterfalls.” And my first ever concert was the FanMail tour at the Hartford Civic Center with Destiny’s Child as the opening act. Kelly Rowland fell and the group kept dancing.

It’s funny because although I loved “Unpretty” when it first came out, I’ve found myself dismissing the song as the years have gone by. I thought I outgrew its lyrics and its message for being too on-the-nose and not being sophisticated enough. Thanks Tom for helping cut through the cynism and red-discovering the beauty in this song.

Posted in: The Number Ones: TLC’s “Unpretty”
#4 
Adam Kushner
Score: 33 | Jul 24th

Just because you stopped paying attention doesn’t make it go away.

Posted in: Neil Young Still Not Ready To Play Concerts: “I Don’t Think It Is Safe In The Pandemic”
#3 
StupidAsshole
Score: 33 | Jul 23rd

Quit respecting these narcissist worshipping internet dorks who pretend they give a shit about music. I’m glad Ye cancelled on these asswipes and I’m glad Cudi dipped too. This crowd of people fucking sucks. Nothing worse than a hypebeast cosplaying as a music dork.

Posted in: Rolling Loud: Kid Cudi Walks Offstage As Crowd Won’t Stop Throwing Bottles, Kanye West Appears With Lil Durk
#2 
bakedbeans
Score: 36 | Jul 22nd

Family vacation is so tight – left my computer at home by accident, so basically no new music all week besides the Jessie Ware song on repeat and then relistening to my other favs from the year on runs.

My mom did say “you really only listen to mellow, whispery music, huh?” And I responded, “well, with you in the car!”

Met pads last night, predictably ruled, don’t ASK me why the photo uploads sideways here:

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best Comments
#1 
dustrock
Score: 44 | Jul 23rd

The only sphere in nature with one Edge

Posted in: U2 Will Play Grand Opening Of World’s Largest Sphere

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR-IN-CHIEF’S CHOICE

raptor jesus
Jul 26th

I’m giving 5 stars, but it’s for Chat Pile.

Posted in: Album Of The Week: Friendship Love The Stranger

more from Shut Up Dude

Hi. It looks like you're using an ad blocker.

As an independent website, we rely on our measly advertising income to keep the lights on. Our ads are not too obtrusive, promise. Would you please disable adblock?