Skip to Content
Columns

Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best Comments

shut up, dude

Your most julia comments of the week are below.

THIS WEEK'S 10 HIGHEST RATED COMMENTS

#10 
dansolo
Score: 24 | Jun 6th

what in 50’s entire career or discography would lead anyone to think he’d be too principled for something like this? He didn’t call his album “Get Rich Unless It Compromises You Morally”

Posted in: 50 Cent Defends Photo With Lauren Boebert
#9 
doboba
Score: 24 | May 31st

People need to stop forcing themselves into trying to like his music out of some grim sense of duty just because Eminem can talk fast.

Posted in: Eminem's New Song "Houdini" Is Really, Really Bad
#8 
bakedbeans
Score: 25 | Jun 4th
  1. Young Jesus - The Fool

  2. Vampire weekend - OGWAU

  3. Hovvdy - Hovvdy

  4. Waxahatchee - Tigers Blood

  5. Ducks LTD - Harm’s Way

  6. Burial - Dreamfear

  7. Vince Staples - Dark Times

  8. Cindy Lee - Diamond Jubilee

  9. Hana Stretton (HM cause it was first released last year

  10. Courting - New Last Name

  11. Phosphorescent - Revelator

Feel like there’s more that I haven’t listened to than in years past. Summer’s just around the corner

Posted in: The 50 Best Albums Of 2024 So Far
#7 
clang
Score: 27 | May 31st

Love that this is the first piece on Stereogum with a Benjamin Netanyahu tag. I assume that'll change when he releases his post-punk EP

Posted in: Radiohead's Jonny Greenwood Performs In Tel Aviv, Reportedly Attends Protest Against Israeli Government
#6 
mt58
Score: 31 | Jun 3rd

What do commenters @DJ Professor Dan, @JonDeutsch, @rollerboogie, @cstolliver @Stobgopper , @ozmoe ,@Phylum of Alexandria! , and @JJ Lives At Leeds have in common? They all have fun and informative articles running this week:

C'mon by, have a look, leave a comment, and join in a fun hang...

https://www.tnocs.com/

Posted in: The Number Ones: Magic!'s "Rude"
#5 
mazloum0
Score: 34 | Jun 4th

I believe that the issue in question is choosing to perform with an Israeli musician in Tel Aviv. No one is making it about being Jewish apart from Greenwood himself.

This conflation of Judaism with zionism/Israel is at the core of every anti-semetic/racist accusation, and it's extremely tiresome.

Posted in: Radiohead's Jonny Greenwood Shares Statement On His Involvement With Israeli Musician Dudu Tassa
#4 
bzen
Score: 35 | May 31st

Oh buddy, you better believe that’s going to change soon.

Posted in: Radiohead's Jonny Greenwood Performs In Tel Aviv, Reportedly Attends Protest Against Israeli Government
#3 
log
Score: 45 | May 31st

There’s a line about how Eminem will hit an eight-year-old in the face with a participation trophy.

Ok, listen. I'm 46 years old. I played little league baseball starting at age 5. We were never very good, so we never won any championships and I'm not even sure our league had championships, yet I have a trophy for every season I played. So, I got participation trophies, basically.

So, first off, this is not a new thing. It's been happening since the early-mid 80's. Why is it that, in the last decade or so, it's talked about like it's a new thing?

Secondly, me being the age that I am, my parents, and the parents of my teammates and the people who ran the league at the time are/were boomers. So, who would have decided to hand out these trophies? Them, of course. We, as little kids, didn't ask for the trophies. They had to decide to hand them out. So why does that generation bitch about them so much?

I don't know if I have a point. It just always bugs me when I hear people around my age start with the "Kids these days, and their participation trophies!" bullshit.

Posted in: Eminem's New Song "Houdini" Is Really, Really Bad
#2 
log
Score: 52 | May 31st

Sometimes I get a little down on myself. Sometimes I don't feel like I'm doing very well at my job or maybe as a father or a husband or even as a person, in general.

Then, I come to Stereogum. I see they've posted an article that is critical of a big celebrity rapper. Then I read the comments and I see that there are people who exist that will go into a website that they have not frequented before, create an account and start fighting in defense of a celebrity that literally could not give less of a shit about them. Just one comment? Oh no. They're digging in. They're replying to ALL of the comments. They have a limited time on this earth, and this is what they're doing with their day.

After all of that, I take a step back. I realize that, you know what? I'm doing pretty good. As bad as things may seem sometimes, at least I've never hit that low of a point in my life. Things are going to be ok, log. Things are going to be ok.

Posted in: Eminem's New Song "Houdini" Is Really, Really Bad
#1 
Callie Petch
Score: 56 | Jun 4th

@James Rettig, I didn't know you were leaving! Thanks for all your words over the years! I've definitely found at least a couple of new favourite bands from your articles! Good luck with grad school and the novel!

Posted in: The 50 Best Albums Of 2024 So Far

THIS WEEK'S EDITOR-IN-CHIEF'S CHOICE

MilkBarPatron
Jun 6th

Did he sneak the bong in or buy it at the merch table?

Posted in: Phish Fan Who Took Bong Hit In The Sphere Permanently Banned From MSG Venues

GET THE STEREOGUM DIGEST

The week's most important music stories and least important music memes.