Last month, Sleigh Bells returned with the new album Jessica Rabbit. And while serving as musical guests on The Late Show With Stephen Colbert last night, the duo performed “I Can Only Stare,” the album’s best song. Sleigh Bells are now far enough from their DIY beginnings that they’re performing with a second guitarist, a backup singer, and a pretty serious light display, but they still have plenty of that old intensity. Alexis Krauss played a little keyboard during the performance and also showed some real vocal firepower. Watch it below.

Jessica Rabbit is out now on Omnian.