Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

While you were busy crying over Rostam, this week we had Gabriela reminiscing about Jenny Lewis’ solo debut, Michael handicapping the battle for NYC summer festival supremacy, Chris serving a hot take on P!ATD, and Tom prematurely evaluating Rihanna’s long-awaited ANTI. Among other things.

THIS WEEK’S 10 HIGHEST RATED COMMENTS

#10  world on a string | Jan 28th Score:20

JV Fall Out Boy is one hell of a dig. I enjoyed it very much.

Posted in: (Panic! At The) Disco Sucks
#9  meat | Jan 28th Score:20

I CAN FINALLY VOTE!!!

Posted in: Premature Evaluation: Rihanna ANTI
#8  meat | Jan 28th Score:21

#proud

Posted in: Premature Evaluation: Rihanna ANTI
#7  dansolo | Jan 22nd Score:22

Never wanted to defend Macklemore but I kinda feel like you’re off base here, Colin. The last few years people have said to Macklemore and Iggy “put up,” show us that isn’t just about money to you. Macklemore tries to make something provocative (keyword “tries”) and thoughtful, tries to show up for the fight, and you double down. It’s not his place to express solidarity? Or make music that will challenge his white fan base? I don’t think he’s tying to make a BLM anthem here, he’d need a lot more black fans to do that. IDK. This song is bad, and painfully earnest, and also just painful… But it’s not going to be a hit. And it seems sincere to me. Unless we’re just saying that anything Macklemore does is bad (which aesthetically might be true but perhaps not politically) then I’m not sure why you’re coming so hard against this. The song is actually a lot more thoughtful than this takedown …

Posted in: Iggy Azalea Responded To Macklemore’s “White Privilege II” And Talib Kweli’s Not Having It
#5  theakronhammer | Jan 26th Score:24

NOOOOOOOOOO THIS IS WORSE THAN ZAYN AND 1D

Posted in: Rostam Quits Vampire Weekend
#4  youngcocoabutter | Jan 28th Score:25

If you get upset by reviews at all you’re a knob

Posted in: (Panic! At The) Disco Sucks
#3 

Doris Montgomery | Jan 22nd Score:25

White Privilege III

Posted in: Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments
#2  Scott Lapatine | Jan 27th Score:32

bae

Posted in: Kanye Goes Off On Wiz Khalifa In The Best Tweetstorm Of All Time
#1  marko | Jan 22nd Score:44

Obviously, if Macklemore wanted to talk about white privilege, he should have gone into music journalism and not record a song about it.

Posted in: Iggy Azalea Responded To Macklemore’s “White Privilege II” And Talib Kweli’s Not Having It

THIS WEEK’S 5 LOWEST RATED COMMENTS

#5  Pixelized Soul | Jan 28th Score:-11

Seriously. This band may suck but it’s not as if the endless stream of booties ‘n’ brags that gets trumpeted around here is chock full of tasteful artistic triumphs.

Posted in: (Panic! At The) Disco Sucks
#4 

Road Burdened | Jan 23rd Score:-12

Oh, sweet Christ, make it stop…The sad thing about Father John Misty is we are going to have to wait through ten years of horrible music before one of his victims comes forward.

Posted in: Father John Misty – “Maybe, Sweet One, You Won’t Have Nightmares Tonight”
#3 

Klyn | Jan 28th Score:-14

kinda agree. if you think this type of article is good, but were annoyed/upset by pitchfork’s Wet review, you’re a hypocrite

Posted in: (Panic! At The) Disco Sucks
#2  agentcooper | Jan 28th Score:-17

Exactly… this worthless shit sucks just as much as the other shit that gets spammed on SG nowadays

Posted in: (Panic! At The) Disco Sucks
#1 

Nelson Miguel Garcia | Jan 28th Score:-24

Sure, the band sucks, but you guys are reaching a new low too

Posted in: (Panic! At The) Disco Sucks

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR-IN-CHIEF’S CHOICE

  meat | Jan 28th Score:7

will they be including festival attendees in their ‘in memoriam’ segment?

Posted in: Electronic Music Is Getting A Televised Awards Show